Everyone Has a Neil: Possibilities of Literacy Desiring in Writer's Studio (Kuby & Gutshall Rucker)
-and-
The Art of Engaging Young Men as Writers (Franco & Unrath)
In the two articles, we begin by focusing on the fact that "children teach US about writing if we give them permission to play-with-materials, listen, watch carefully, and then respond by opening curricular spaces for them to live out their literacy desirings as multimodal writers" (pgs. 314-315). Products can be very diverse and teach us about individuality in creation. But we find that the future and the end products are not necessarily the focus of either article. It is in the process where the learning really occurs. What is becoming as children are in the process of creating? During the process, students are invited to collaborate with peers to strengthen pieces by listening to recommendations. Similarly, in VTS, "participants consider and contribute diverse perspectives to group meaning-making" (p. 27).
The aim of the authors in the Neil article was to "demonstrate the sophisticated and collaborative literacy desirings of children when they are given time, space, materials, and permission to create multimodally" (p. 315). In VTS, there is an emphasis on visual literacy, where "through the acts of viewing, responding, and visually representing during the prewriting phase" (p. 28).
In Neil's classroom, Tara had to be thoughtful in her planning and know her curriculum expectations well so that she could be more flexible and embrace the unexpected ways her students created their stories. Tara began by putting out lots of different materials for writing, then witnessed the children "intra-acting-with-materials," while in VTS (during the discussions), there are carefully sequenced visual art images that engage and sustain learners. From observation (in the Kuby article), the authors noted that the children were not always "intentional and/or sure about what they were creating" with their wide variety of materials. "At times, Tara stepped in and shared examples from previous years or from her own experiences, so a child who needed more prompting had a range of options to consider" (p. 316), while in VTS, the teacher stays neutral without contributing information or insight into dialogue. Discussions are facilitated, not directed in VTS, much like the peer conversations in the Kuby article. However, main questions are focused and repeated in VTS to keep the conversation moving and new ideas forming from one piece of artwork.
Neil's creations were fissures that departed from "expected ways of being." For instance, experiences with Neil's inventive personal narrative game demonstrates that "the writing process or cycle is not always linear" (p. 319), as we discussed in class on the 11th. An interesting question is then posed: how do I, as a teacher, embrace fissures in my teaching plans? Do I allow freedom from "proper" and "conventional" techniques as both articles showcase? Do I allow individual interpretations as an "additional avenue for understanding and responding" (p. 29)?
Lastly, I thought it was interesting that both articles discussed allowing the exploration of aggression and conflict (in these cases, among boys) within the classroom environment. I have always struggled with knowing how to address these types of output with students, and it makes sense that students need space to "bring in pop culture and their experiences outside of school even if they are steeped with violence and injustices" (p. 323) and it motivates their passions and provides them with opportunities to share their interests with others, like the partnership between Neil and Zane.
We have to trust that children need time to play with materials so they can create for themselves, but also teach others how to use materials in various ways as well...as the VTS article mentions, these are ways to stimulate "literacy achievement in ways that more common instructional approaches do not" (p. 28). This type of play leads to a positive self-efficacy within students because they are experimenting with their own ideas and it is leading them to thinking that they might not otherwise apply. They are taking risks, persevering through tough choices and using their peer relationships to expand their ideas even further.
Friday, June 12, 2015
Wednesday, June 10, 2015
Reading Summary #3
For this reading summary, I'm going to attempt to combine my discussion of the three readings since they contained similar information. I'm leaning heavily on the What Works article, because it was by far my favorite reading of the evening because of the examples used and the ease with which the author wrote.
I read the Practice Theory chapter first and appreciated that it discussed examples of quantitative and qualitative data in an easy to understand way really helped me. On page 52, I highlighted that "Yes/No questions or Likert-style questions are likely to work well" in quantitative research, while in a qualitative case study, using interviews is a good method of data collection. Another important note was that the quality of data is more important than the quantity. I always feel like when I have had to write research papers in the past that I struggled to find the right number of data sources (mostly because I didn't know what I was really looking for until now), but I will admit I never paid as much attention to the quality.
Quantitative data still seems to be kind of daunting to me (and "not very sexy" according to Brewer in the Inquiry text), and qualitative data sources seem so much more interesting or real in the type of research I am drawn to, such as those involving face-to-face interactions. But quantitative research is needed in our field because it "provides a foundation for understanding relationships between conducting research, teaching, and assessment" (p. 125).
I was so drawn to the examples mentioned in the What Works article, beginning with the analogy that researchers are like collectors. However, "unlike a collector who simply accumulates, as a researcher you have a focused purpose: to answer the question you've developed using the information you've gathered" (p. 69). When beginning to collect data, the author suggests to start "with the source that brought you to your question in the first place." I also liked these suggestions for finding data everywhere:
In addition to her research journal, she includes interviews, written responses by the interviewees, and field notes.
"Using yourself as a data source is essential" (p. 71)
"Many teacher-research projects depend almost entirely on collections of student work" (p. 72)
As for interviewing, when we "allow the conversation to take it's natural course, it will hold far more value than if you stage it using predesigned questions whose answers you've already anticipated" (p. 75)
I also like the challenge on page 80 to list data sources I haven't considered.
Finally, when analyzing data and finding results, presenting straightforward facts is key, so organizing data into a conclusion and in a way that makes sense is very important. The Inquiry text definitely was an easy read to help me break down qualitative research in a way that I understood better. Hey, as mentioned in the What Works article, even "at my age I still see that major growth is possible for me" -Jan Reeder (p. 70).
Side note: I know Kenzie mentioned this on Lore, but the fact that the Inquiry AND the Practice Theory texts are literally coming apart at the seams is DRIVING ME BANANAS!!!!!!!
---AAAAAAAND *scene*---;)
I read the Practice Theory chapter first and appreciated that it discussed examples of quantitative and qualitative data in an easy to understand way really helped me. On page 52, I highlighted that "Yes/No questions or Likert-style questions are likely to work well" in quantitative research, while in a qualitative case study, using interviews is a good method of data collection. Another important note was that the quality of data is more important than the quantity. I always feel like when I have had to write research papers in the past that I struggled to find the right number of data sources (mostly because I didn't know what I was really looking for until now), but I will admit I never paid as much attention to the quality.
Quantitative data still seems to be kind of daunting to me (and "not very sexy" according to Brewer in the Inquiry text), and qualitative data sources seem so much more interesting or real in the type of research I am drawn to, such as those involving face-to-face interactions. But quantitative research is needed in our field because it "provides a foundation for understanding relationships between conducting research, teaching, and assessment" (p. 125).
I was so drawn to the examples mentioned in the What Works article, beginning with the analogy that researchers are like collectors. However, "unlike a collector who simply accumulates, as a researcher you have a focused purpose: to answer the question you've developed using the information you've gathered" (p. 69). When beginning to collect data, the author suggests to start "with the source that brought you to your question in the first place." I also liked these suggestions for finding data everywhere:
In addition to her research journal, she includes interviews, written responses by the interviewees, and field notes.
"Using yourself as a data source is essential" (p. 71)
"Many teacher-research projects depend almost entirely on collections of student work" (p. 72)
As for interviewing, when we "allow the conversation to take it's natural course, it will hold far more value than if you stage it using predesigned questions whose answers you've already anticipated" (p. 75)
I also like the challenge on page 80 to list data sources I haven't considered.
Finally, when analyzing data and finding results, presenting straightforward facts is key, so organizing data into a conclusion and in a way that makes sense is very important. The Inquiry text definitely was an easy read to help me break down qualitative research in a way that I understood better. Hey, as mentioned in the What Works article, even "at my age I still see that major growth is possible for me" -Jan Reeder (p. 70).
Side note: I know Kenzie mentioned this on Lore, but the fact that the Inquiry AND the Practice Theory texts are literally coming apart at the seams is DRIVING ME BANANAS!!!!!!!
---AAAAAAAND *scene*---;)
Tuesday, June 9, 2015
Reading Summary / Research Translation #2
Practice Theory Chapter 5:
This chapter "focuses on how researchers put together all the parts in order to formulate a sound study" (p. 37). Researchers will choose their methodologies to approach their research in a way that is flexible but within some parameters. Some methodologies frequently used in art education are action research (to enhance and study one's own practice), arts-based research (to include the art process), case study (to involve in-depth observation of the teaching strategies of an individual or a small group), ethnographic research (to investigate the cultural system of a group), historical research (to collect, evaluate, synthesize, and interpret data related to past events), narrative/autobiographical research (to tell the stories of everyday experiences of participants), portraiture research (to represent a person or situation in an in-depth manner), quasi-experimental research (to study cause and effect relationships), survey research (to describe or characterize a large group of people from a small representative sample), and theoretical research (to analyze key features of a concept in order to make connections to a particular field).
Methodology can also be categorized as quantitative or qualitative; quantitative being structured data that can be measured, and qualitative being a method where the focus is on the qualities of the situation or phenomenon being researched. After narrowing down one's research topic to a research problem to a purpose statement, one must narrow further to a focused question or hypothesis, which also considers methodology. I appreciated the breakdown on page 43 that mentioned creating quantitative vs qualitative research questions"if a researcher's approach to a study is quantitative, the researcher will likely deal with a hypothesis, a prediction about the relationship among variables, or a yes/no question" while qualitative researchers choose questions that "seek to understand", "explore a process", or "report the stories."
It was interesting to read the two short glimpses into the plans of the case study and action research study. These are good examples of how to break down a plan of attack before beginning research.
A/R/Tography Chapter 5:
W-O-W. Nicole Porter's chapter was amazing and totally energized me after a long day of reading about research processes! Last summer in Survey, I started toying with the idea to do training with art teachers (both in and outside my district) to begin to think of themselves as artist-teachers (culminating in a gallery exhibition) for my master's project, and this chapter gave me great insight and resources to continue working toward that goal. Some quotes that I absolutely loved were:
"I struggled at first to meld the two persons of artist and teacher" (p. 105)
"What's it for? What is it for, anyway? Students make art because they are in a class and the teacher marks it. WHY would a teacher make something?" (p. 106)
"For me it is not possible to separate the artist 'within' from the art teacher 'without'" - Laurie Ball
"The artist nurtures the teacher by keeping in touch with the very processes and material she wishes to teach, and the teacher feeds the artist by allowing more time and experience to objectify those very personal processes through art history and art criticism and aesthetics" -Laurie Ball
"I want for my students what I have with my own art--an enjoyment and satisfaction that comes with creation for myself, not for some arbitrary judge. I want them to see themselves as artists" (p. 107)
"The artist-teacher model is essential to good pedagogy" -George Szekely
Seeing Porter's work in the classroom "encouraged students to reflect on how they created pieces and helped them not to be too focused on the end result" (p. 112) *side note, I've been trying to find a way to discuss with the librarian at my school that I would like to be help her with a new creative space at school that she is in charge of (why, I'm not really sure...but I digress) and I thought that Porter's student explained what I've been trying to explain to her in terms of my place there as a specialist in the area (I'm paraphrasing to fit my needs) It's a way for students to see where they can look to to get ideas, not to rip them off, but to look at and say, this is how a particular process works, now how can I change it and make my own.
I love the idea of the weekly studio night (or afternoon in my case), where students could come in and work on their own projects. I want students to see themselves as artists and see the classroom as a studio, their studio to create their work. I am coming closer to transforming myself into an artist-teacher. It's still a struggle for me to "find the time"...aka the oldest excuse in the book, and one that the author would argue is not a healthy relationship with either passion. But I want to be able to connect to my students on the level Ms. Porter does with her students. I want to see the ways practicing my own art can effect the way I teach. I want to experience Porter's model that was a catalyst for change in her classroom.
Research Translation - Inquiry in Action Chapter 16:
I will straight-up admit that after reading the last, wonderful article in A/R/Tography, this one was a STRUGGLE to get through. I didn't feel like this article lined up very well with the translation criteria, but then again, I'm not sure I was doing it right...
Research Problem: The research problem was broadly stated as a focus on the evaluation of partnership programs in Art Ed and transformative evaluation as research. The research was discussed as being important because of the need for art educators to evaluate their programs (with administrators and curriculum planners) so that they could determine and reflect on the efficacy and impact of their program and strengthen programs where needed. If I am understanding correctly, the term "program evaluation" was defined involving: the systematic use of a variety of research methodologies and instruments; investigation based on established program goals, often of curriculum or partnership programs; determinations regarding the effectiveness of programs; recommendations for making decisions about program continuation or change; multiple stakeholders, including higher education, classroom teachers, community partners, and students; and transformative, reflexive practice, leading to self-efficacy on the part of art educators and arts organizations.
The goals in the example study were clearly stated, but it did seem like there was a lot of varying information that they were trying to get out of their groups.
Literature Review: The review of previous research is well organized, and seem to be relevant. The oldest source cited was a Dewey article from 1934, and the second oldest was from 1994. The most current was from 2011.
The was not a literature review at the end of the example.
Research Questions or Hypotheses: A question posed by the author was "why do art educators need to know about program evaluation?" One of the answers given was that it is essentially because of funding, but the author stated that it was more important for teachers to evaluate their programs so that they understand the impact of their lessons, off-site partnerships that are effected, and opportunities afforded by their program.
Another question was "is evaluation really research?" which I thought was a more important question, given the main focus of the article. The author answers this by graphing the similarities and differences between evaluation and research.
Data Sources/Sampling: In the example study mentioned, it says "stakeholders" were partnered with the external evaluator to "contribute to research skills and guide practitioners to reflect on the data in order to formulate programmic recommendations"...so for this type of research it seems that the data sources are varying?
Measurement Tools: I think I need someone to describe what this would look like in this type of study? I'm not sure what I'm looking for here.
Methodology/Procedures: In the example study, it states that the "methodology for data collection and analysis included group interviews with the fine arts team and 4th-grade teachers, two electronic surveys of teachers, and group interviews with 4th-and 5th-grade students (would this be the data source?) The rest of the procedures are very clearly stated: there was an initial meeting to discuss the various programs, there was an initial survey given because "teacher-reported survey data was vague", and then there was a follow-up survey to determine how the program was utilized the remainder of the year...but it says only eight teachers responded, whereas in the first survey given, 22 faculty members responded.
Results: the results of the example study were easy enough to understand, but the conclusions drawn from the survey were all over the place and it seems like focusing in on one area might have made for a more meaningful report. At the end of the chapter, the author states that because goals-based evaluations are conducted to determine how programs are functioning, it seems like the research was answered in the way it should have been, but it seems like a very convoluted process to me. Granted, because of the way this type of research is conducted, the good thing is that the study ends with recommendations for restructuring the program. Since the results did not have very consistent participation, I don't know how accurate the results were, so consequently, many people may be unhappy with the suggestions for restructuring.
I am so open to redirection if I wasn't looking at the correct information when answering these questions! I feel like I was kind of off-track with this translation!
This chapter "focuses on how researchers put together all the parts in order to formulate a sound study" (p. 37). Researchers will choose their methodologies to approach their research in a way that is flexible but within some parameters. Some methodologies frequently used in art education are action research (to enhance and study one's own practice), arts-based research (to include the art process), case study (to involve in-depth observation of the teaching strategies of an individual or a small group), ethnographic research (to investigate the cultural system of a group), historical research (to collect, evaluate, synthesize, and interpret data related to past events), narrative/autobiographical research (to tell the stories of everyday experiences of participants), portraiture research (to represent a person or situation in an in-depth manner), quasi-experimental research (to study cause and effect relationships), survey research (to describe or characterize a large group of people from a small representative sample), and theoretical research (to analyze key features of a concept in order to make connections to a particular field).
Methodology can also be categorized as quantitative or qualitative; quantitative being structured data that can be measured, and qualitative being a method where the focus is on the qualities of the situation or phenomenon being researched. After narrowing down one's research topic to a research problem to a purpose statement, one must narrow further to a focused question or hypothesis, which also considers methodology. I appreciated the breakdown on page 43 that mentioned creating quantitative vs qualitative research questions"if a researcher's approach to a study is quantitative, the researcher will likely deal with a hypothesis, a prediction about the relationship among variables, or a yes/no question" while qualitative researchers choose questions that "seek to understand", "explore a process", or "report the stories."
It was interesting to read the two short glimpses into the plans of the case study and action research study. These are good examples of how to break down a plan of attack before beginning research.
A/R/Tography Chapter 5:
W-O-W. Nicole Porter's chapter was amazing and totally energized me after a long day of reading about research processes! Last summer in Survey, I started toying with the idea to do training with art teachers (both in and outside my district) to begin to think of themselves as artist-teachers (culminating in a gallery exhibition) for my master's project, and this chapter gave me great insight and resources to continue working toward that goal. Some quotes that I absolutely loved were:
"I struggled at first to meld the two persons of artist and teacher" (p. 105)
"What's it for? What is it for, anyway? Students make art because they are in a class and the teacher marks it. WHY would a teacher make something?" (p. 106)
"For me it is not possible to separate the artist 'within' from the art teacher 'without'" - Laurie Ball
"The artist nurtures the teacher by keeping in touch with the very processes and material she wishes to teach, and the teacher feeds the artist by allowing more time and experience to objectify those very personal processes through art history and art criticism and aesthetics" -Laurie Ball
"I want for my students what I have with my own art--an enjoyment and satisfaction that comes with creation for myself, not for some arbitrary judge. I want them to see themselves as artists" (p. 107)
"The artist-teacher model is essential to good pedagogy" -George Szekely
Seeing Porter's work in the classroom "encouraged students to reflect on how they created pieces and helped them not to be too focused on the end result" (p. 112) *side note, I've been trying to find a way to discuss with the librarian at my school that I would like to be help her with a new creative space at school that she is in charge of (why, I'm not really sure...but I digress) and I thought that Porter's student explained what I've been trying to explain to her in terms of my place there as a specialist in the area (I'm paraphrasing to fit my needs) It's a way for students to see where they can look to to get ideas, not to rip them off, but to look at and say, this is how a particular process works, now how can I change it and make my own.
I love the idea of the weekly studio night (or afternoon in my case), where students could come in and work on their own projects. I want students to see themselves as artists and see the classroom as a studio, their studio to create their work. I am coming closer to transforming myself into an artist-teacher. It's still a struggle for me to "find the time"...aka the oldest excuse in the book, and one that the author would argue is not a healthy relationship with either passion. But I want to be able to connect to my students on the level Ms. Porter does with her students. I want to see the ways practicing my own art can effect the way I teach. I want to experience Porter's model that was a catalyst for change in her classroom.
Research Translation - Inquiry in Action Chapter 16:
I will straight-up admit that after reading the last, wonderful article in A/R/Tography, this one was a STRUGGLE to get through. I didn't feel like this article lined up very well with the translation criteria, but then again, I'm not sure I was doing it right...
Research Problem: The research problem was broadly stated as a focus on the evaluation of partnership programs in Art Ed and transformative evaluation as research. The research was discussed as being important because of the need for art educators to evaluate their programs (with administrators and curriculum planners) so that they could determine and reflect on the efficacy and impact of their program and strengthen programs where needed. If I am understanding correctly, the term "program evaluation" was defined involving: the systematic use of a variety of research methodologies and instruments; investigation based on established program goals, often of curriculum or partnership programs; determinations regarding the effectiveness of programs; recommendations for making decisions about program continuation or change; multiple stakeholders, including higher education, classroom teachers, community partners, and students; and transformative, reflexive practice, leading to self-efficacy on the part of art educators and arts organizations.
The goals in the example study were clearly stated, but it did seem like there was a lot of varying information that they were trying to get out of their groups.
Literature Review: The review of previous research is well organized, and seem to be relevant. The oldest source cited was a Dewey article from 1934, and the second oldest was from 1994. The most current was from 2011.
The was not a literature review at the end of the example.
Research Questions or Hypotheses: A question posed by the author was "why do art educators need to know about program evaluation?" One of the answers given was that it is essentially because of funding, but the author stated that it was more important for teachers to evaluate their programs so that they understand the impact of their lessons, off-site partnerships that are effected, and opportunities afforded by their program.
Another question was "is evaluation really research?" which I thought was a more important question, given the main focus of the article. The author answers this by graphing the similarities and differences between evaluation and research.
Data Sources/Sampling: In the example study mentioned, it says "stakeholders" were partnered with the external evaluator to "contribute to research skills and guide practitioners to reflect on the data in order to formulate programmic recommendations"...so for this type of research it seems that the data sources are varying?
Measurement Tools: I think I need someone to describe what this would look like in this type of study? I'm not sure what I'm looking for here.
Methodology/Procedures: In the example study, it states that the "methodology for data collection and analysis included group interviews with the fine arts team and 4th-grade teachers, two electronic surveys of teachers, and group interviews with 4th-and 5th-grade students (would this be the data source?) The rest of the procedures are very clearly stated: there was an initial meeting to discuss the various programs, there was an initial survey given because "teacher-reported survey data was vague", and then there was a follow-up survey to determine how the program was utilized the remainder of the year...but it says only eight teachers responded, whereas in the first survey given, 22 faculty members responded.
Results: the results of the example study were easy enough to understand, but the conclusions drawn from the survey were all over the place and it seems like focusing in on one area might have made for a more meaningful report. At the end of the chapter, the author states that because goals-based evaluations are conducted to determine how programs are functioning, it seems like the research was answered in the way it should have been, but it seems like a very convoluted process to me. Granted, because of the way this type of research is conducted, the good thing is that the study ends with recommendations for restructuring the program. Since the results did not have very consistent participation, I don't know how accurate the results were, so consequently, many people may be unhappy with the suggestions for restructuring.
I am so open to redirection if I wasn't looking at the correct information when answering these questions! I feel like I was kind of off-track with this translation!
Reading Summary / Research Translation #1
(This is just a draft of what I have completed regarding this assignment so that I can move on to #2...as a placeholder so that my posts will be in order when I finish this one. Yes, I'm OCD like that ;))
Inquiry in Action Chapters 1-3:
The first chapter of Inquiry in Action focuses on the "why" of research (why it is socially relevant) and the steps that should be taken in the research process. In contemporary art education, we must constantly determine what constitutes art knowledge NOW, according to author Kerry Freedman. Knowledge is constructed by individuals and groups and is always changing depending on context. Art education, specifically, "functions at the intersection of the visual arts and the social sciences," (p. 1) which makes art educators well-equipped for researching and documenting the relevance of art for all students and the culture they live in.
Research creates new knowledge and helps "contribute to the intellectual domain and growth of the professional field, enabling other researchers to construct arguments" that can "guide practice, support changes in policy, and advance student learning" (p. 2). A researcher must first establish research goals in order to find theories that support and/or answer questions that might emerge as "holes" in their field. A researcher should also establish goals that could help people "maintain a sense of vision by working at the edges of research and theory" in order to push boundaries that were previously established (p. 3). Because the "quality of a research project is determined, in part, by whether it results in new knowledge" a researcher must form questions on which to base their research that are written in a clear manner, questions that are answerable, and questions that are relevant to theory development in their field and practice. Next, the researcher must develop research skills so that they can "review, critique, and construct better arguments" (p.6). And finally, the researcher must construct a theory based on their research. "It is the relationship between theory and practice that promotes critical dialogue and establishes the fluid boundaries of art education, connecting members of the field through their collaborative development of this relationship, and helping to establish a professional community" (p. 5).
The next chapter discusses what the researcher needs to know about the process of researching. Good advice about choosing a topic, designing a proposal, and seeking evidence, are all given in examples that are broken down into easy to follow worksheets, though I will admit that it definitely still seems daunting.
Chapter 3 breaks the research process down even further (specifically focusing on the literature review) by discussing how to begin the search for articles that can be used for an annotated bibliography without it seeming like finding a needle in a haystack. Using these tips then helps the researcher fine-tune their research goal, noting that the "search and review process should not be limited to the beginning of the study, but should be considered an integral and ongoing activity" (p.27). Rereading often, and seeking peer reviews helps ensure a tight and thoughtful paper, and providing appropriate headings and subheadings helps guide the researchers thinking to help direct the reader to the conclusion. As Smilan states, "a well-established literature review will lend credibility to your study. The literature you read will ultimately help you to formulate your research interests and support your discussion of results and research conclusions" (p. 27).
Practice Theory Chapter 3:
Research Translation:
Oddly, the article I chose (before I read the Inquiry chapters) just happened to be one co-authored by Kerry Freedman (the article's other author is Patricia Stuhr). I picked the article because the title, Curriculum Change for the 21st Century: Visual Culture in Art Education, drew me because of the ideals we have discussed in this program for years. After a preliminary read-through, it definitely seemed to be an article that tied in with my group's topic: Art Teacher Practice/Innovation in Art Education. When I began to type and took notice of the author's names, I realized I had read Kerry Freedman's work in previous classes and in the aforementioned chapters.
The questions are clearly stated as the article discusses the importance of a shift from traditional practices in fine arts teaching, toward a more broad range of cultural studies within visual arts. The authors state that the purpose of the writing is to "discuss art education in terms of the broadening realm of visual culture and to theorize about curriculum change". They go on to mention that though visual culture has begun to have a place in art education, much work still needs to be done to "promote appropriate interpretations and applications of visual culture."
Inquiry in Action Chapters 1-3:
The first chapter of Inquiry in Action focuses on the "why" of research (why it is socially relevant) and the steps that should be taken in the research process. In contemporary art education, we must constantly determine what constitutes art knowledge NOW, according to author Kerry Freedman. Knowledge is constructed by individuals and groups and is always changing depending on context. Art education, specifically, "functions at the intersection of the visual arts and the social sciences," (p. 1) which makes art educators well-equipped for researching and documenting the relevance of art for all students and the culture they live in.
Research creates new knowledge and helps "contribute to the intellectual domain and growth of the professional field, enabling other researchers to construct arguments" that can "guide practice, support changes in policy, and advance student learning" (p. 2). A researcher must first establish research goals in order to find theories that support and/or answer questions that might emerge as "holes" in their field. A researcher should also establish goals that could help people "maintain a sense of vision by working at the edges of research and theory" in order to push boundaries that were previously established (p. 3). Because the "quality of a research project is determined, in part, by whether it results in new knowledge" a researcher must form questions on which to base their research that are written in a clear manner, questions that are answerable, and questions that are relevant to theory development in their field and practice. Next, the researcher must develop research skills so that they can "review, critique, and construct better arguments" (p.6). And finally, the researcher must construct a theory based on their research. "It is the relationship between theory and practice that promotes critical dialogue and establishes the fluid boundaries of art education, connecting members of the field through their collaborative development of this relationship, and helping to establish a professional community" (p. 5).
The next chapter discusses what the researcher needs to know about the process of researching. Good advice about choosing a topic, designing a proposal, and seeking evidence, are all given in examples that are broken down into easy to follow worksheets, though I will admit that it definitely still seems daunting.
Chapter 3 breaks the research process down even further (specifically focusing on the literature review) by discussing how to begin the search for articles that can be used for an annotated bibliography without it seeming like finding a needle in a haystack. Using these tips then helps the researcher fine-tune their research goal, noting that the "search and review process should not be limited to the beginning of the study, but should be considered an integral and ongoing activity" (p.27). Rereading often, and seeking peer reviews helps ensure a tight and thoughtful paper, and providing appropriate headings and subheadings helps guide the researchers thinking to help direct the reader to the conclusion. As Smilan states, "a well-established literature review will lend credibility to your study. The literature you read will ultimately help you to formulate your research interests and support your discussion of results and research conclusions" (p. 27).
Practice Theory Chapter 3:
Research Translation:
Oddly, the article I chose (before I read the Inquiry chapters) just happened to be one co-authored by Kerry Freedman (the article's other author is Patricia Stuhr). I picked the article because the title, Curriculum Change for the 21st Century: Visual Culture in Art Education, drew me because of the ideals we have discussed in this program for years. After a preliminary read-through, it definitely seemed to be an article that tied in with my group's topic: Art Teacher Practice/Innovation in Art Education. When I began to type and took notice of the author's names, I realized I had read Kerry Freedman's work in previous classes and in the aforementioned chapters.
The questions are clearly stated as the article discusses the importance of a shift from traditional practices in fine arts teaching, toward a more broad range of cultural studies within visual arts. The authors state that the purpose of the writing is to "discuss art education in terms of the broadening realm of visual culture and to theorize about curriculum change". They go on to mention that though visual culture has begun to have a place in art education, much work still needs to be done to "promote appropriate interpretations and applications of visual culture."
Wednesday, June 18, 2014
Five Minds for the Future by Howard Gardner
Howard Gardner writes in his book Five Minds for the Future that “there are certain kinds of minds
people will need if they—if we—are to thrive in the world during eras to come”
(page 1). These minds have each
been important throughout time and each can continuously be developed in our
students and ourselves. The five
minds are the disciplined mind, the synthesizing mind, the creative mind, the
respectful mind, and the ethical mind.
Each mind has differences, but each can, and should, overlap in order for
one to become a well-rounded individual.
The disciplined mind relates to the intellect of a person,
one who has studied at least ten years and has mastered at least one way of
thinking. Because this is a more
scholarly approach to learning, the vernacular must be honed in a particular
subject. A disciplined individual, therefore, masters
key literacies enabling them to build upon previously learned information and
encourage them to continue to develop their research in areas that interest
them. In the art classroom,
a disciplined mind can be developed by practicing technical skills and offering
historical information about art and artists.
A person with a synthesizing mind “takes information from
disparate sources, understands and evaluates that information objectively, and
puts it together in ways that make sense” (page 2). Gardner states that there are eight types of synthesis:
narratives, taxonomies, complex concepts, rules and aphorisms, powerful
metaphors (as well as images and themes), embodiment without words, theories,
and metatheory. This mind helps
prove that actual learning has taken place in students by allowing them to
teach what they have been taught.
It shows the transference of information happening within the
classroom. Specifically,
in the art classroom, an individual with a synthesizing
mind would develop multiple and diverse visual representations to embody
an idea in their personal artwork as well as interpret big ideas and questions
posed by other artists in their work.
While the first three minds are important in order to
succeed individually, without the respectful mind to welcome differences
amongst peers, a person will flounder in the outside world. A respectful person seeks to understand
other cultures and listens to the opinions and virtues of another to have the
ability to work with others toward a common goal. Strategies for this mind in the art classroom are
prevalent. Art educators can have
students view artifacts and visual images from other cultures and use Visual
Thinking Strategies and critiques in order to learn to engage in respectful
dialogue with one another. As
educators in general, we should be cognizant of the way we are modeling
respectful relationships amongst different groups.
Lastly, the ethical mind “ponders the nature of one’s work
and the needs and desires of the society in which one lives” (page 3). The ethical mind bounces off of the
respectful mind in a more abstract way by conceptualizing “how workers can
serve purposes beyond self-interest and how citizens can work unselfishly to
improve” (page 3). An educator’s
role is vastly important in developing this mind because of the fact that
children are spending more of their waking hours at school than anywhere
else. As with the respectful mind,
modeling is important in fostering the ethical mind in students. Students want to be a part of a
structured classroom where they are part of the rule-making process. Showing students that fairness,
truthfulness, loyalty, and integrity are important in the art classroom will
encourage them to use ethical rules outside of the classroom.
Monday, June 9, 2014
Blog Reflection Day 4: Facilitating Engagement with the Art-Making Process
One of the sections in Outcome III of Carroll's text is Facilitating Dialogue and Discourse About Student Work. In it, Carroll says that including critiques and adding dialogue into the art classroom helps cultivate the community within the classroom and helps students discover meaning in their artwork and the work of others. Learning to respect the processes and value "making and responding to art" is a crucial part of our jobs as art educators. This particular section came at the perfect time considering Mary Franco came in to discuss Visual Thinking Strategies with our class prior to doing this reading.
A couple of the ways Carroll (via Barrett) suggests engaging students in serious and thoughtful discussions are by: placing "primary responsibility for talking during the critique on the viewers of the artwork"; being "a facilitator of thoughtful discussions" and "preventing random, unconnected, and ill-conceived comments"; carefully formulating questions; placing emphasis on interpreting versus evaluating. All things we would encourage and do during VTS.
So I searched for an article with these suggestions in mind and found this one called Tools to Enhance Young Children's Thinking by Angela K. Salmon. In it, Salmon talks about creating "thinking routines" with students in order to promote critical thinking skills in students as young as elementary age. She describes a technique called See/Think/Wonder which is almost exactly like VTS, down to asking similar questions like "what makes you say that?" to help students interpret their answers with proper justification. Asking proper questions, Salmon says, "help children see that thinking goes beyond recognizing objects and memories to being a method for solving problems and understanding the world" (page 30).
Building a culture of thinking is key to helping give the arts footing in it's fight for relevance because of the link it creates between the mental processes of learning: comparing, inferring, explaining, and analyzing. A proper culture of thinking can also help students can create more meaningful artwork of their own if they understand better "what's going on inside their heads" and can become more aware of their "own language and thoughts" (page 30).
A couple of the ways Carroll (via Barrett) suggests engaging students in serious and thoughtful discussions are by: placing "primary responsibility for talking during the critique on the viewers of the artwork"; being "a facilitator of thoughtful discussions" and "preventing random, unconnected, and ill-conceived comments"; carefully formulating questions; placing emphasis on interpreting versus evaluating. All things we would encourage and do during VTS.
So I searched for an article with these suggestions in mind and found this one called Tools to Enhance Young Children's Thinking by Angela K. Salmon. In it, Salmon talks about creating "thinking routines" with students in order to promote critical thinking skills in students as young as elementary age. She describes a technique called See/Think/Wonder which is almost exactly like VTS, down to asking similar questions like "what makes you say that?" to help students interpret their answers with proper justification. Asking proper questions, Salmon says, "help children see that thinking goes beyond recognizing objects and memories to being a method for solving problems and understanding the world" (page 30).
Building a culture of thinking is key to helping give the arts footing in it's fight for relevance because of the link it creates between the mental processes of learning: comparing, inferring, explaining, and analyzing. A proper culture of thinking can also help students can create more meaningful artwork of their own if they understand better "what's going on inside their heads" and can become more aware of their "own language and thoughts" (page 30).
Friday, June 6, 2014
Blog Post Day 4: Judy Chicago's The Dinner Party
I chose Encounter 14 (or find the download here) the final encounter, because it seemed like an idea that my upper elementary students would be able to grasp and have fun with. The ideas included in the encounter that students could use for investigation include:
*thinking about who would be invited to their dinner party, what would be served, how the food would be served, etc.
*role playing the women who were included at the table of The Dinner Party.
*role playing women newly invited to the table: women from history or from contemporary times (students should also consider women who have had influence on them personally!).
*designing their own table settings/dining room for their personal dinner party.
While I think it's very important to make the connection to women in history, I like the idea of including women important to my students so they can have a personally meaningful experience while making their own artwork. It would be fun to have a real dinner party at the end of the unit and invite the women my students created the artwork for. As the guests of honor, we would let them use the table setting and hear about why they are an important guest at their student's dinner party.
*thinking about who would be invited to their dinner party, what would be served, how the food would be served, etc.
*role playing the women who were included at the table of The Dinner Party.
*role playing women newly invited to the table: women from history or from contemporary times (students should also consider women who have had influence on them personally!).
*designing their own table settings/dining room for their personal dinner party.
While I think it's very important to make the connection to women in history, I like the idea of including women important to my students so they can have a personally meaningful experience while making their own artwork. It would be fun to have a real dinner party at the end of the unit and invite the women my students created the artwork for. As the guests of honor, we would let them use the table setting and hear about why they are an important guest at their student's dinner party.
![]() |
| Image courtesy: http://www.brooklynmuseum.org/images/eascfa/dinner_party/place_settings/TDP_Place_Settings_Sig.jpg |
Thursday, June 5, 2014
Blog Post Day 3: Art:21 Artist El Anatsui
Alright, first let's get this out of the way, here's a link to a video that will save you some embarrassment later called How do YOU say...El Anatsui. I'm going to be honest, I have loved this artist's work for years now and never knew the correct pronunciation. I have also never done much research on his background, so this was a good opportunity to delve a little into his process and the ideas behind his work.
I chose this Art21 video, in which El Anatsui discusses CHANGE. How lives change when moving from one culture to another, how the introduction of alcohol changed the lives of Africans, how using recycled materials to create artwork can change their meaning. In his personal life and work, he discusses how concentrating on the practice of art changes his role as an artist, and how his artwork can be installed differently in every setting so that it is constantly changing shape.
Connecting
Questions:
When in your life has change been a good thing or a bad thing? How did this change effect you personally? How has a change you have made effected others? What are some huge changes that you can think of that have changed the course of history? How do those changes in history effect you now, personally?
Creating:
Students will create an invention that can cause some kind of change in their lives. Whether it be as simple as a machine to help them with chores like making their beds or taking out the trash, or complicated like traveling through time or across great distances in order to speak with someone greatly missed. Think of how the invention would work, how it would look and draw a detailed picture. Think about what kind of changes in your life could this invention cause? Are they all good, or could some of them be potentially bad? Students will draw their invention but not show it to anyone at this point.
Responding
Questions:
How do you feel about the fact that El Anatsui employs others to create his pieces? What if you tried to explain your invention to someone for them to draw?
Creating:
Students will partner up and each will explain their invention in detail for the other to draw. Once finished, we will have a discussion about the similarities and differences between the artist's and their partner's separate visions.
Creating
Questions:
El Anatsui often uses materials from alcohol recycling stations as a comment on the history of colonialism and to draw connections between consumption and wastefulness. What recyclable items could be found at your home that could be changed in a way that would relay a message about you, your life, your family?
Creating:
Students will gather recycled artifacts that relate to their home. Maybe they often eat the same brand of cereal over and over so they bring in the empty boxes and use the cardboard for a sculpture or weaving. Maybe they have a collection of Mason jars used for canning or storing that they could use to create a sculpture or installation. Or they could just use the lids somehow. For me, personally, I would be able to find bags of empty Coke cans at my mother's house that I could use to create an homage to her.
Presenting
Because El Anatsui wants his work to change and evolve constantly, he allows others to install it without sending specific instructions. For presentation of projects, students will choose a friend's work and think deeply about how the artwork could/should be presented. What new type of meaning can someone's artwork take on if it is installed in a setting not intended by the artist?
I chose this Art21 video, in which El Anatsui discusses CHANGE. How lives change when moving from one culture to another, how the introduction of alcohol changed the lives of Africans, how using recycled materials to create artwork can change their meaning. In his personal life and work, he discusses how concentrating on the practice of art changes his role as an artist, and how his artwork can be installed differently in every setting so that it is constantly changing shape.
| Dusasa I, 2007. My favorite piece at the Nelson Atkins Museum of Art in KC |
Connecting
Questions:
When in your life has change been a good thing or a bad thing? How did this change effect you personally? How has a change you have made effected others? What are some huge changes that you can think of that have changed the course of history? How do those changes in history effect you now, personally?
Creating:
Students will create an invention that can cause some kind of change in their lives. Whether it be as simple as a machine to help them with chores like making their beds or taking out the trash, or complicated like traveling through time or across great distances in order to speak with someone greatly missed. Think of how the invention would work, how it would look and draw a detailed picture. Think about what kind of changes in your life could this invention cause? Are they all good, or could some of them be potentially bad? Students will draw their invention but not show it to anyone at this point.
Responding
Questions:
How do you feel about the fact that El Anatsui employs others to create his pieces? What if you tried to explain your invention to someone for them to draw?
Creating:
Students will partner up and each will explain their invention in detail for the other to draw. Once finished, we will have a discussion about the similarities and differences between the artist's and their partner's separate visions.
Creating
Questions:
El Anatsui often uses materials from alcohol recycling stations as a comment on the history of colonialism and to draw connections between consumption and wastefulness. What recyclable items could be found at your home that could be changed in a way that would relay a message about you, your life, your family?
Creating:
Students will gather recycled artifacts that relate to their home. Maybe they often eat the same brand of cereal over and over so they bring in the empty boxes and use the cardboard for a sculpture or weaving. Maybe they have a collection of Mason jars used for canning or storing that they could use to create a sculpture or installation. Or they could just use the lids somehow. For me, personally, I would be able to find bags of empty Coke cans at my mother's house that I could use to create an homage to her.
Presenting
Because El Anatsui wants his work to change and evolve constantly, he allows others to install it without sending specific instructions. For presentation of projects, students will choose a friend's work and think deeply about how the artwork could/should be presented. What new type of meaning can someone's artwork take on if it is installed in a setting not intended by the artist?
Wednesday, June 4, 2014
Blog Reflection Day 2: Art Education Aims in the Age of New Media and Matter Matters
Elizabeth Delacruz writes in her article Art Education Aims in the Age of New Media: Moving Toward Global Civil Society that digital media courses are increasingly being taught in K-12 schools by a variety of teachers that are not in the art education field. The problem with this is that it is turning what could be exciting and engaging processes into another "set of mundane tasks to be prescribed, taught, drilled, and tested in the current standards-driven educational climate."
As art educators, Delacruz writes that our classroom environments build a sense of regard for others that "requires directing varied instructional practices toward inquiry, making, and doing about things that greatly matter." If we take on and engage in teaching digital media in our classrooms by keeping up with innovations in technology, facilitating virtual learning and citizenship through social networking and aligning our curriculum with new media literacy education, we may find "far-reaching and deeply satisfying opportunities to create, participate in, and help shape global civil society" alongside our students.
As art educators, Delacruz writes that our classroom environments build a sense of regard for others that "requires directing varied instructional practices toward inquiry, making, and doing about things that greatly matter." If we take on and engage in teaching digital media in our classrooms by keeping up with innovations in technology, facilitating virtual learning and citizenship through social networking and aligning our curriculum with new media literacy education, we may find "far-reaching and deeply satisfying opportunities to create, participate in, and help shape global civil society" alongside our students.
***
In Matter Matters: Art Education and Material Culture Studies, Chapter 14: The Practice of Collecting, Jeanne Nemeth states that collecting has become embedded in our culture and is a common social activity that is part of our daily lives. Children, specifically, "are enthusiastic collectors of objects significant to their own histories and cultural identities" (page 126). I can remember when I was in elementary school that at least one year I was asked to bring in something I collected. I can't remember exactly what the purpose of the assignment was, but it does seem that my teacher was only interested in what our collections were. Nemeth writes that most studies about children's collections "concentrate on what is collected and do not attempt to explain why one is attracted to certain objects or how they are selected, displayed, or used." My collection was of books. I brought in boxes and boxes of books I had read. It was fun for me to see all the covers and titles in front of me, to look at the colors and just the sheer number of stories I had enjoyed. But no one ever asked me what had drawn me to specific series. No one wondered if I displayed them in a certain way. I never knew why I chose books to collect other than because I was an avid reader. But why not go to the library and borrow the books? What was it that drew me to the act of owning these hundreds of books?
To research why children have collections, Nemeth chose a group of seventh graders and interviewed them based on the following categories: "Objects of Importance, Definition of a Collection, Content in the Collection, Process Involved in Collecting, Use and Display of Collections, and Personal Connections to the Objects Collected," as well as questioned students as to what the relationship was from their collections to their "identity, family relationships, community activities, personal aesthetic considerations, and creative opportunities."
The data received from these interviews showed how collecting serves many purposes for the students. Self-expression is a big factor in why students chose to collect objects. Some collections grow from an interest or passion in learning about a subject, or to personally connect them to history. They use them to employ "non-linear time frames for reciting family memories" and to create "new narratives." They use them to imagine and play. Some collections grow because of a personal design aesthetic of a particular room. They create "theatrical shelf displays; and more informal, altar-type assemblages." "Most importantly," Nemeth says on page 129, "students found collections to be a way to express their own interests and personalities and to make life meaningful."
Nemeth proposes several ways to introduce lessons using students' personal collections. One I especially liked was the photography assignment using the collection as subject matter. Students could create a still life from their collection, or rearrange them into a fantasy scenario for photographing. Having discussions about collections is a great way to introduce students to artists who collect and why they do so. Andy Warhol and Joseph Cornell are two major artists who used collections in their work. Nemeth lists many other contemporary artists that can be discussed as examples for "exploring how artists learn and work through objects and visual materials" (page 132).
We as art educators are in an ideal position to encourage social and political investigations surrounding collecting using "cross-disciplinary curriculum ideas for learning about art practice, the mass arts, and material culture in a post-modern context" (page 126). This is important so that we can involve and encourage students to "make connections in the classroom to their own cultural environments and collected artifacts" because "incorporating students' own material objects for use in art production enables students to respond to objects in which they have knowledge, interest, and, at times, passion" (page 130).
Blog Post Day 2: Material/Art Object
The material object I have chosen is the couch. Since my husband and I have recently moved into a new home, we have been thinking/talking a lot about couches lately. We've discussed just the right one to buy that would fit the style we are going for. We've discussed selling our old one, for how much, on what website. After we sold the old one, we lived without one for a week at our apartment. I must say, you don't realize how important having a comfy couch in your living arrangement is until you don't have one to plop down on after a long day.
Here is a picture of our old couch:
Here is a picture of our old couch:
And a couple of the new couch, that I haven't had much of a chance to enjoy:
When the thought of using couches came into my mind, I immediately remembered an artist who shows a lot in Kansas City, Adolfo Martinez. He studied for a bit at the Art Institute and won a Charlotte Street award years ago. He also has paintings in the Nerman Museum collection as well as one that was just acquired by the Arrowhead Stadium art project.
He creates sofa-size paintings of...sofas...that incorporate Mexican motifs. They have a humor and personality that engages viewers:
![]() |
| Images courtesy Leopold Gallery, Kansas City |
I think you can tell a lot about someone based off of the couch they have in their home, don't you?
Tuesday, June 3, 2014
Blog Reflection Day 1: Debating Visual Culture in Art Education
In her article Rescuing Art from 'Visual Culture Studies,' Michelle Marder Kamhi starts off with a bang by saying that adding visual culture studies into art education is akin to treating the Nike of Samothrace and Michelangelo's David on par with Barbie and Ken. She argues that "the main emotions inspired by the Visual Culture approach are all on the side of anger, resentment, and moral outrage, leaving little place for such feelings as love, pride, compassion, admiration, tenderness, courage, grief, hope, honor, reverence, or joy" and that the latter feelings are often "stifled by the detached, analytical approach adopted in Visual Culture Studies."
In one of the more appalling sections of her article, Kamhi even goes so far as to essentially say photographs cannot be considered true works of art because "while one assumes that everything about a painting is the result of choices made by the artist, one can never be sure, in looking at a photograph, which aspects were selected as important or meaningful by the photography, and which were accidental or incidental." She states that in order for something to be considered a work of art, the artist must feel a personal connection to their subject and that connection should convey meaning through depictive and expressive means versus through symbols. It can be readily argued, however, that many photographers specifically choose subject matter based on the personal connection to their subjects and also that many painters convey meaning through symbols. Kamhi maintains that "teachers who emphasize the need to help students "decode" images place an undue emphasis on symbolic content" and that the qualities that make something a work of art, such as in Jan van Eyck's The Arnolfini Portrait, are the "natural" aspects of its subject matter; the sober facial expressions, the gesture of their joined hands. In my opinion, this argument by Kamhi is very contradictory, because understanding these qualities about a painting is very similar to decoding. Especially when discussing artwork with young students, these associations with body language and facial expressions are the most easily recognized and therefore "decoded."
Paul Duncum's article Seven Principles for Visual Culture Education contrasts Kamhi's views by stating that we are in need of principles for contemporary curriculum which coincide with the world we are currently living in. He feels that while "early 20th-century elements and principles remain important" they are only "one way to consider the formal qualities of images."
Duncum lists seven principles for examining imagery, whether they be considered fine art or pop culture. The principles are Power, Ideology, Representation, Seduction, Gaze, Intertextuality, and Multimodality. Using these principles, students are able to gather their own meaning while looking at art and advertisements...basically all imagery that surrounds and bombards them on a daily basis. These principles enable students to gather meaning from the world they live in and make associations and connections to artwork they may not otherwise have an understanding of.
Isn't this type of knowledge more important for our students to possess than the outdated views expressed by Kamhi? Our students can't make associations about paintings from the past until they understand the cultural contexts of their own world. Not allowing students to learn to appreciate and make their own meaning from all types of artwork would probably appall the artist's Kamhi mentions in her article. And their peers that she disregards (abstract artists) would, I imagine, wholeheartedly disagree that their implications haven't been understood when people come to museums to view their work. Art cannot possibly fit into the narrow category that Kamhi describes, and we must facilitate open discussions with our students using Duncum's principles to help them understand that artwork goes beyond a well-painted representation and is more than meets the eye.
In one of the more appalling sections of her article, Kamhi even goes so far as to essentially say photographs cannot be considered true works of art because "while one assumes that everything about a painting is the result of choices made by the artist, one can never be sure, in looking at a photograph, which aspects were selected as important or meaningful by the photography, and which were accidental or incidental." She states that in order for something to be considered a work of art, the artist must feel a personal connection to their subject and that connection should convey meaning through depictive and expressive means versus through symbols. It can be readily argued, however, that many photographers specifically choose subject matter based on the personal connection to their subjects and also that many painters convey meaning through symbols. Kamhi maintains that "teachers who emphasize the need to help students "decode" images place an undue emphasis on symbolic content" and that the qualities that make something a work of art, such as in Jan van Eyck's The Arnolfini Portrait, are the "natural" aspects of its subject matter; the sober facial expressions, the gesture of their joined hands. In my opinion, this argument by Kamhi is very contradictory, because understanding these qualities about a painting is very similar to decoding. Especially when discussing artwork with young students, these associations with body language and facial expressions are the most easily recognized and therefore "decoded."
Paul Duncum's article Seven Principles for Visual Culture Education contrasts Kamhi's views by stating that we are in need of principles for contemporary curriculum which coincide with the world we are currently living in. He feels that while "early 20th-century elements and principles remain important" they are only "one way to consider the formal qualities of images."
Duncum lists seven principles for examining imagery, whether they be considered fine art or pop culture. The principles are Power, Ideology, Representation, Seduction, Gaze, Intertextuality, and Multimodality. Using these principles, students are able to gather their own meaning while looking at art and advertisements...basically all imagery that surrounds and bombards them on a daily basis. These principles enable students to gather meaning from the world they live in and make associations and connections to artwork they may not otherwise have an understanding of.
Isn't this type of knowledge more important for our students to possess than the outdated views expressed by Kamhi? Our students can't make associations about paintings from the past until they understand the cultural contexts of their own world. Not allowing students to learn to appreciate and make their own meaning from all types of artwork would probably appall the artist's Kamhi mentions in her article. And their peers that she disregards (abstract artists) would, I imagine, wholeheartedly disagree that their implications haven't been understood when people come to museums to view their work. Art cannot possibly fit into the narrow category that Kamhi describes, and we must facilitate open discussions with our students using Duncum's principles to help them understand that artwork goes beyond a well-painted representation and is more than meets the eye.
Sunday, May 25, 2014
Reflection Summation
I can't BELIEVE I'm finally at this point, y'all! It has been a roller coaster of a semester and I'm already feeling lighter and more peaceful than I have in months. I can honestly say that's in part due to my kiddos helping me create my final project. Seeing it all come together today in the little video I made makes me endlessly happy...
Here's how we created our project:
First, I had my students each trace and cut out one of their hands. Next, I gave them a formal technique and color to apply to their hands...
For Kindergarten, students drew a small self portrait with red oil pastel, then painted over the whole hand with light red liquid watercolor.
Here's how we created our project:
First, I had my students each trace and cut out one of their hands. Next, I gave them a formal technique and color to apply to their hands...
For Kindergarten, students drew a small self portrait with red oil pastel, then painted over the whole hand with light red liquid watercolor.
First grade demonstrated their knowledge of mixing two primaries to make a secondary by adding red to yellow to create orange. I loved the texture of the brushstrokes on each hand.
Speaking of texture, second grade used two different types of texture (implied and actual) to add yellow to their hands, both with crayon and paint. They loved trying out the different textures I had for them to rub with the crayon, and they thought it was hysterical that we were going to use plastic forks to print instead of using them to eat with.
Third grade used strips of different values of green construction paper to make 3D loops, curls, and accordions that they glued to their hands.
Fourth grade had a treasure hunt to find blue scraps in magazines and around the room that they collaged together.
Fifth grade enjoyed coming up with various line patterns that they filled their hands with and colored purple.
Once the hands were finished, I chose a group of students to design and put together our hand mural while I supervised and took a photo of each step. I cleared my biggest bulletin board (10 1/2' wide x 6' tall), put up black paper, and gave them an idea of what I was looking for: a giant kaleidoscope, mandala, ripple-thingy. They knew immediately what I meant...LOL. I suggested we start in the middle with our reds, our K's, our littlest and most vulnerable, so they could be protected by their older peers. From there, my team added and took down, thought and thought some more, layered, questioned, and completed our masterpiece. It was so fun I wish I could have videotaped it to show everyone.
After the pictures were taken, I put them into iMovie and uploaded it to You Tube so our process could be watched step-by-step. It reminds me of an art dance. It's a joyous, flowing burst of colors and cooperation. All hands on deck (well, not all...even though we had a huge "canvas" to work with, we ran out of room to use everyone's hand, but I think I will use the rest at the beginning of next year to make new designs with other groups of kiddos that didn't get to help with this one. We can sprinkle them on bulletin boards around the school to welcome everyone back to school in the fall!). All hands working together to support and love one another. Yes, these hands show our art elements and principles, but they also show the most important aspects of being part of our art classroom: they show that we can create meaning with the simplest materials and feel free to experiment and try and do and PLAY, which, as I've mentioned are my personal goals in my quest to becoming a successful, progressive, post-modern, 21st century teacher.
Here's our video (I once again tried to embed it and it keeps telling me "no video found" which is ridiculous, but anyway, I put the link below and will try to embed it later).
My students requested the thumbs up at the end so I could show my hand as well. Heart. Melted.
And here is a better photo of the final project:
Saturday, May 24, 2014
Revisiting Education Tree and Pre/Current Thinking
The last week and a half I've been planning/beginning work on my summative reflection piece and haven't found a chance to sit down and collect my thoughts on the process until now. I've been on autopilot trying to tie up loose ends at school and with our new home after my school-wide art show. The art show was my big focus after a trying few weeks dealing with a great loss. Without things slowing down any, but at least with the stress of the show out of the way, I've had a chance to do more quick projects with my students that they can enjoy and then take home, rather than keep at school and work on multiple class periods.
http://mrl.li/1er0MKs
*I can't for the life of me remember how I embedded the last edition of my mural.ly. I have tried several different options, but none of them will work like the last time, just when I need it to most. C'est la vie. The link above should take you to the mural.ly page to take a look, as needed.
One project I decided to have them work on will be the basis for my summative piece. I had each student trace their hand and I gave each class a color, materials, and guidelines as to the techniques they would use to add their color to their hands. The reason I asked them to use their hands is because I think it's a good metaphor for their role in my struggles this year. They've used their hands to be the pat on the back I've needed, given me the round of applause, the wave in the hall, or the thumbs up that have gotten me through this semester. When their hands raise in the air after I've asked a question, I know I've accomplished what I came to do on a daily basis. My final project is a mural they helped me put together using the hands they created the last couple of weeks. I'm still putting the finishing touches on it, so more on that to come.
Reading through my blog posts is something I've done regularly, as I often related them to one another from week to week. I notice a happier, more optimistic tone at the beginning of the semester, versus my later posts. They say that the end of the winter months are the hardest for teachers (and students for that matter, what with all the cramming for standardized testing, which I've discussed a lot in my posts). This is the first year I've reeeeeeeally felt that struggle at school. There was just so much going on personally that I lost sight of my role in my student's lives. I touched on this in my two video reflections. At least when I read through them, knowing what was going on, I can gather from my undertone that I was concerned about the meaning that my students were making in art. I was concerned that my curriculum wasn't up to par. Those are still major concerns for me, but especially after I tried the lessons I used for the videos, I knew I was on the right track in finding a happy medium between teaching the basics to my kiddos, and allowing them to have a hand (there's that key word to my summative again) in their own learning.
I have also revisited my education tree and have added multiple branches. It was interesting for me to go back to it and reconsider who else and what else I needed to add to make it whole. I'm still not sure it's "finished," but like I mentioned in my self-portrait from week 8, artists seem to always question if their work is finished or not...
http://mrl.li/1er0MKs
*I can't for the life of me remember how I embedded the last edition of my mural.ly. I have tried several different options, but none of them will work like the last time, just when I need it to most. C'est la vie. The link above should take you to the mural.ly page to take a look, as needed.
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Week 8: Post Modern Portrait
I wanted to go ahead and post this because it was finished...or is it finished? Isn't that the age-old question for artists? I ran out of time over the weekend to post the rest of my blog entries. Among other things going on in my life, as a few of you might know, my husband and I recently closed on a house that we are doing major renovations ourselves (and with the help of my in-laws) and we can't move in till they are mostly finish. We now have just over two weeks left on our countdown.
I've been stretching myself WAY too thin this year and I'm about at my breaking point...and frankly, my portrait is kind of the embodiment of that feeling, so I thought it would be a good idea to reflect on that.
Once I had my composition figured out, I continued to manipulate the layers so that the four photographs looked as though they were moving away from the central drawing. To me, this created the feeling that the central drawing was being pulled or stretched apart.
My process started with a pencil self-portrait which was about 6" x 9". I try to draw from life at least every week or so just to keep that muscle active:
I thought about the portrait quite a bit, trying to figure out where to go next. I look alert, but pretty neutral emotion-wise in the drawing and wondered how I could play around with it and add layers that reflected the gamut of emotions I had been feeling when I made the piece and how they related to my year.
I found these two portraits to be very inspiring while Pinterest prowling, obviously...
courtesy flickr.com
courtesty of washingtonpost.com
They were both so colorful and playful and I felt really embodied the spirit of the Gude articles. I loved the layering and wanted to try and layer images similarly for my self-portrait. I would have loved to do some screen printing, but I didn't have access to materials needed for such an endeavor, so I turned to Photoshop to help me on my layering path, a la the Andy Warhol. I have only started using Photoshop regularly within the past year, so I'm still a relative newbie, but I'm learning so that I can figure out ways to bring more digital media into my curriculum for my students to try.
I thought of two photographs that had been taken of me where I was in the midst of laughing. Moments caught of genuine happiness. I wanted to use those to represent the part of me this year that really has "lightened up" as Gude mentioned in Playing, Creativity, Possibility. I'm on the right track in my teaching (especially after rethinking and reflecting more thoroughly on how I'm teaching and what for during this class) and I really do feel like students are enjoying art now more than ever. And I know that they are the part of this year that has really mattered in the grand scheme of things. Their education and their openness to try new things and their genuine excitement is what gets me through even the hardest days. I found the photos I was looking for and manipulated them over and over until I felt they were ready to be layered onto my original drawing.
On the flip side of the coin is the part of me that has been struggling this year. In my week 7 Read and Reflect, I wrote:
Gude lists conditions that might inhibit student's creativity: "self-consciousness in front of peers, over-scheduling that doesn't leave time for daydreaming, hours spent immersed in passively watching TV or actively playing video games, schools that focus on getting the one right answer, and a society that judges success on standardized test scores and the size of bank accounts" (page 33). I can definitely see these things affecting my students, which could account for some of the feet dragging I've seen with them this year more than ever.These things, among others, have been weighing heavily on my mind. Both for my student's sake, and for mine. To show this in my piece, I set up a camera and took various photos of myself changing the shutter speed as I walked away or turned my head, similar to the poses in the Andy Warhol portrait. The results were opposite the joy portrayed in the other two photos, which is what I was looking for. I chose two, manipulated them similarly to the first and layered them on the opposite side of the picture.
Once I had my composition figured out, I continued to manipulate the layers so that the four photographs looked as though they were moving away from the central drawing. To me, this created the feeling that the central drawing was being pulled or stretched apart.
I tried some variations with color, as in the pieces I used for my inspiration, but couldn't come up with a scheme that spoke to me more than the basic black and white at this point. When I'm feeling a bit more playful and spontaneous, I might investigate other ways of adding layers of color. I have actually been thinking since I made the piece weeks ago about how I could get a quality copy printed so I could try manipulating it with paint or pastels. Who knows where a layering process similar to this could take me this summer when I have more time to experiment more!
Sunday, May 11, 2014
Week 12: Video Assignment #2
Pre-thinking reflections: Since I just posted my reflection from my week 6 video, I have the information from it at the forefront of my mind, which is good. I made notes in the weeks between the filming of my first lesson and the filming of my second lesson which helped me decide that I wanted to switch grade levels and go to a group that could have time for more of a meaningful discussion (one of my goals is creating new ways my curriculum can become more meaningful
to my students), like 4th and 5th grade. I noted I wanted to find a lesson where we could talk about a contemporary abstract artist, as an introduction to my students and so I could listen to their ideas and thoughts about pieces. I had read an article about Gerhard Richter and made a note that I wanted to specifically ask the question: "Why do you think his artwork is worth millions of dollars?" Mostly because I thought it would lead to some juicy discussions. It seems like a subject that students of this age can grasp, but have more open-mindedness about than most adults. The other goal I was trying to accomplish was again that I wanted to differentiate/restructure my teaching routine in order to give students more freedom to experience new materials and thought processes. With the lesson I came up with, I knew I could do accomplish this goal, because it isn't something I have ever tried before, much less introduced to my students.
Pre-viewing reflections: I really thought I hit the nail on the head with this lesson. I was able to try it with a smaller group because it was Take Your Child to Work Day so I only had about half the students I normally would have. We began by looking at a large image of one of Richter's works and kind of VTSesque-ing students thoughts on what they saw, what they liked, didn't like, etc. I then explained how Richter makes his work with a big squeegee and how we were going to experiment with layers of color using a technique similar. Essentially they were going to learn about an artist's process and try a new way of creating a painting that they've never tried before. My students were so excited when I demonstrated the process of dripping the paint on the paper and scraping it with a ruler. Then switching colors and doing it again...and again. Some went WILD with the paint. They kept exclaiming that it was the best art day because they were able to make paintings that were completely different than the next person's. They felt like they had absolute freedom and were so happy! What an eye-opener! The pure joy they were feeling was contagious and it made me realize that this is what it should feel like every day. I've had such a rough year, but this was IT. I really think these kids could've stayed in the artroom and made paintings all day, which would've been amazing because I think if they were able to keep at it and start thinking about they colors they were creating and the amounts of paint they were using to get a certain effect, their paintings would eventually have matured beyond the experimental stages. We unfortunately only had a limited amount of time, however, and I wanted to be able to stop and have a discussion at the end since I wasn't able to the last time I filmed.
Post-viewing reflections: The beginning and doing part of the lesson went pretty much how I explained above. At the end of the lesson, the students were still reeling from the excitement of the process. Watching them excitedly bounce around and want to share their thoughts makes me so happy. We talked about how things could've been different. They came up with ideas about how they could have made their paintings even better by using less paint (so it wouldn't smear around quite as much) or using less colors. On the other hand, some wish they would've used more colors...mostly I think because they wanted to try them all to see what they would look like together. They talked about how the bright colors made them feel so happy and how interesting it was that everyone's papers were so different. I'm surprised at how free they truly felt during the process. One student says at the end that she felt like she could just let out all her creativity with this project. It makes me want to do it every day, and it makes me remember how much fun my job can be when I open myself up to new projects and am not so worried about what's going on outside my classroom doors. I look happier in this video than I've seen myself in quite a while. I'm not sure how well I tied in my goal of creating meaning into the lesson, but for sure I was able to allow freedom to try new processes. The only other thing I might have done if I had had more time is shown a short video I found of Richter making his big pieces so we could compare our process with his.
http://www.nowness.com/day/2011/10/7/1668/gerhard-richter-painting
Here are some of the works created that day. All different. All stunning:
Pre-viewing reflections: I really thought I hit the nail on the head with this lesson. I was able to try it with a smaller group because it was Take Your Child to Work Day so I only had about half the students I normally would have. We began by looking at a large image of one of Richter's works and kind of VTSesque-ing students thoughts on what they saw, what they liked, didn't like, etc. I then explained how Richter makes his work with a big squeegee and how we were going to experiment with layers of color using a technique similar. Essentially they were going to learn about an artist's process and try a new way of creating a painting that they've never tried before. My students were so excited when I demonstrated the process of dripping the paint on the paper and scraping it with a ruler. Then switching colors and doing it again...and again. Some went WILD with the paint. They kept exclaiming that it was the best art day because they were able to make paintings that were completely different than the next person's. They felt like they had absolute freedom and were so happy! What an eye-opener! The pure joy they were feeling was contagious and it made me realize that this is what it should feel like every day. I've had such a rough year, but this was IT. I really think these kids could've stayed in the artroom and made paintings all day, which would've been amazing because I think if they were able to keep at it and start thinking about they colors they were creating and the amounts of paint they were using to get a certain effect, their paintings would eventually have matured beyond the experimental stages. We unfortunately only had a limited amount of time, however, and I wanted to be able to stop and have a discussion at the end since I wasn't able to the last time I filmed.
Post-viewing reflections: The beginning and doing part of the lesson went pretty much how I explained above. At the end of the lesson, the students were still reeling from the excitement of the process. Watching them excitedly bounce around and want to share their thoughts makes me so happy. We talked about how things could've been different. They came up with ideas about how they could have made their paintings even better by using less paint (so it wouldn't smear around quite as much) or using less colors. On the other hand, some wish they would've used more colors...mostly I think because they wanted to try them all to see what they would look like together. They talked about how the bright colors made them feel so happy and how interesting it was that everyone's papers were so different. I'm surprised at how free they truly felt during the process. One student says at the end that she felt like she could just let out all her creativity with this project. It makes me want to do it every day, and it makes me remember how much fun my job can be when I open myself up to new projects and am not so worried about what's going on outside my classroom doors. I look happier in this video than I've seen myself in quite a while. I'm not sure how well I tied in my goal of creating meaning into the lesson, but for sure I was able to allow freedom to try new processes. The only other thing I might have done if I had had more time is shown a short video I found of Richter making his big pieces so we could compare our process with his.
http://www.nowness.com/day/2011/10/7/1668/gerhard-richter-painting
Here are some of the works created that day. All different. All stunning:
Week 6: Video Assignment #1
For my first video, I wanted to try a lesson that would give my younger students an opportunity to try out various 2D supplies and give them free reign of their creative expression, while giving them one guideline: to create a self portrait. Self portrait projects can have a tendency to be frustrating for students if they think they're not "good enough" to draw figures and faces. Luckily with kindergarteners, that's not usually a major hinderance, so I chose them for my first video.
1. My thoughts on the lesson/first reaction to viewing: to begin, we talked on the carpet about what a self portrait is. It felt like a pretty basic introduction to me, without any major issues. My kindergarteners this year are the squirreliest group of kiddos I have ever encountered, plus there are 30 of them in each class, so there's always a lot of stopping to redirect. It didn't seem like more than usual today. After our discussion, the students went to their seats, and I had table helpers pass out papers and get basic supplies like pencils, oil pastels, and markers. I told the class that I wanted them to think about the things we talked about during carpet time and draw a picture of themselves in their favorite place. The other guideline was that they needed to fill the picture plane. While they were drawing, I asked that they think about their favorite place and what makes it special to them. When they were drawing, I got out primary watercolors so they could also experiment with paint and practice color mixing without Things seemed to go very well and I got some amazing results:
My intention was to have time for a discussion at the end of the class period, but students worked right up until we had about five minutes left to clean up.
After watching the lesson, I felt like things went pretty smoothly. As I mentioned above, there was a lot of redirection during discussion time on the carpet, but for the most part, while students were working, there weren't a lot of problems. I like to have this time at the beginning of each class to introduce the lesson and talk about reasons behind artmaking and artists, but I may need to cut it shorter for my little ones and ease them into it as they get older. For instance, make sure I only spend a couple minutes at first, then gradually get to the point where they can have longer and more quality discussions.
Work time also seemed to go very smoothly, with the exception of a few students who I watched just start scribbling and smearing without seeming to give much thought. I'm still not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing, because at the least, they were interested in the materials. It's not surprising, but it was good for me to witness that with so many materials to choose from, students really did stay more focused than they do when lessons are more rigid and step-oriented. I liked what I was seeing. The majority of the students were so engaged in their mark-making and in how the materials felt in their hands. The feel of the oil pastels seem to really intrigue them, which was funny to watch. In fact a couple of times I witnessed students drawing with the pastels on their hands to see how they felt. They liked to watch the paint bleed together on their paper. It was pretty much what I expected, but nice to witness the pure joy of expressive artmaking.
2. Thinking about my goals/second reaction to viewing: I never specifically articulated my goals in week 3, but they were woven into my reflection. To be more clear, two of the goals I was thinking about during my video lesson were: 1) Differentiating/restructuring my lessons to give students more freedom to choose their paths, and 2) Creating new ways my curriculum can become more meaningful to my students. I felt like this assignment would be a good way to work on both of those goals, and it seemed to be perfect for both. As I mentioned above, my students are more focused when they have more control over what's being created. And the results speak for themselves. The students made beautiful portraits using a variety of media and the stories that are entwined with them were rich and joyous (we discussed the portraits at a later date since we ran out of time during class).
3. Speaking from a student's perspective: I'm going to speak from the perspective of Brian, one of my scribblers...Okay, it's art class, so I need to follow this red line to the carpet and find a place to sit down to listen to Mrs...Mrs...K? No, Mrs. Taylor talk. I'm going to sit here. No, I'm going to sit here next to this box of paper. Oh, I love looking at these lights. What are they called? The ones that have the colored bubbles that float up and down. I wonder what's inside there. What's inside this box of paper. Lots of paper. I want to put my hands inside of it. Oooops, Mrs. K, no Mrs. Taylor saw me. She gave me that look. I still want to put my hands in here. She's looking away, I'm going to try it ag---okay, she said I need to move my table spot. I like these chairs, they don't have backs and they're round so I can swing around on them. There's all these bars at the bottom so I can stick my feet through them. Oh, we're getting paper now! And pencils! And weird sticky crayons! AND MARKERS???? YES! What are we supposed to do? I'll ask Mrs. K. No, Mrs. Taylor. Draw a picture of myself in my favorite place. Hmmm, what's my favorite place? I'm going to use this sticky crayon to draw myself in a tornado!!!!! Here's my dog and he's in the tornado too!! That would be so weird! I like green so I'm going to use green. What about this white one. White on a white piece of paper. HAHA! I wonder how this sticky stuff feels on my hands. It doesn't feel as weird as I thought. I wonder if the sticky stuff on my hand will come off on the paper. Yep, it does. What else is happening in this picture? I think the tornado is in the middle of the colored bubble light! I'm going to use the water paint to make the water stuff that's in the light! WHOA, the water paint makes bubbles on top of the sticky crayon just like the bubble light! The paint won't stay on the sticky crayon! It just rolls around! COOOOOOL!! Well, class must be over. Everyone is cleaning up. I wonder if I can throw the green sticky crayon into the bucket from way over here. No, Mrs. K is looking at me. No, Mrs. Taylor. Oh, she called my table, so I need to line up. I wonder if I go really slow if I can be the caboose. I liked that art class. There were so many things to look at and try! And drawing myself in a tornado with my dog is really funny. I'm going to walk all the way down the hall with my hand on the wall so I can feel the bumps...that's going to be so weird!
I like to think that this is actually how Brian's mind works. He's very sweet, just very interested in everything that is going on around him. That's why I think the lesson really does work well for students like him, because they can always come up with a narrative for their pictures, and being able to experiment with the various materials is always very exciting for them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





























