(This is just a draft of what I have completed regarding this assignment so that I can move on to #2...as a placeholder so that my posts will be in order when I finish this one. Yes, I'm OCD like that ;))
Inquiry in Action Chapters 1-3:
The first chapter of Inquiry in Action focuses on the "why" of research (why it is socially relevant) and the steps that should be taken in the research process. In contemporary art education, we must constantly determine what constitutes art knowledge NOW, according to author Kerry Freedman. Knowledge is constructed by individuals and groups and is always changing depending on context. Art education, specifically, "functions at the intersection of the visual arts and the social sciences," (p. 1) which makes art educators well-equipped for researching and documenting the relevance of art for all students and the culture they live in.
Research creates new knowledge and helps "contribute to the intellectual domain and growth of the professional field, enabling other researchers to construct arguments" that can "guide practice, support changes in policy, and advance student learning" (p. 2). A researcher must first establish research goals in order to find theories that support and/or answer questions that might emerge as "holes" in their field. A researcher should also establish goals that could help people "maintain a sense of vision by working at the edges of research and theory" in order to push boundaries that were previously established (p. 3). Because the "quality of a research project is determined, in part, by whether it results in new knowledge" a researcher must form questions on which to base their research that are written in a clear manner, questions that are answerable, and questions that are relevant to theory development in their field and practice. Next, the researcher must develop research skills so that they can "review, critique, and construct better arguments" (p.6). And finally, the researcher must construct a theory based on their research. "It is the relationship between theory and practice that promotes critical dialogue and establishes the fluid boundaries of art education, connecting members of the field through their collaborative development of this relationship, and helping to establish a professional community" (p. 5).
The next chapter discusses what the researcher needs to know about the process of researching. Good advice about choosing a topic, designing a proposal, and seeking evidence, are all given in examples that are broken down into easy to follow worksheets, though I will admit that it definitely still seems daunting.
Chapter 3 breaks the research process down even further (specifically focusing on the literature review) by discussing how to begin the search for articles that can be used for an annotated bibliography without it seeming like finding a needle in a haystack. Using these tips then helps the researcher fine-tune their research goal, noting that the "search and review process should not be limited to the beginning of the study, but should be considered an integral and ongoing activity" (p.27). Rereading often, and seeking peer reviews helps ensure a tight and thoughtful paper, and providing appropriate headings and subheadings helps guide the researchers thinking to help direct the reader to the conclusion. As Smilan states, "a well-established literature review will lend credibility to your study. The literature you read will ultimately help you to formulate your research interests and support your discussion of results and research conclusions" (p. 27).
Practice Theory Chapter 3:
Research Translation:
Oddly, the article I chose (before I read the Inquiry chapters) just happened to be one co-authored by Kerry Freedman (the article's other author is Patricia Stuhr). I picked the article because the title, Curriculum Change for the 21st Century: Visual Culture in Art Education, drew me because of the ideals we have discussed in this program for years. After a preliminary read-through, it definitely seemed to be an article that tied in with my group's topic: Art Teacher Practice/Innovation in Art Education. When I began to type and took notice of the author's names, I realized I had read Kerry Freedman's work in previous classes and in the aforementioned chapters.
The questions are clearly stated as the article discusses the importance of a shift from traditional practices in fine arts teaching, toward a more broad range of cultural studies within visual arts. The authors state that the purpose of the writing is to "discuss art education in terms of the broadening realm of visual culture and to theorize about curriculum change". They go on to mention that though visual culture has begun to have a place in art education, much work still needs to be done to "promote appropriate interpretations and applications of visual culture."
No comments:
Post a Comment