Friday, June 12, 2015

Article Comparison, Post #4

Everyone Has a Neil: Possibilities of Literacy Desiring in Writer's Studio (Kuby & Gutshall Rucker)
-and-
The Art of Engaging Young Men as Writers (Franco & Unrath)

In the two articles, we begin by focusing on the fact that "children teach US about writing if we give them permission to play-with-materials, listen, watch carefully, and then respond by opening curricular spaces for them to live out their literacy desirings as multimodal writers" (pgs. 314-315).  Products can be very diverse and teach us about individuality in creation.  But we find that the future and the end products are not necessarily the focus of either article.  It is in the process where the learning really occurs.  What is becoming as children are in the process of creating?  During the process, students are invited to collaborate with peers to strengthen pieces by listening to recommendations.  Similarly, in VTS, "participants consider and contribute diverse perspectives to group meaning-making" (p. 27).

The aim of the authors in the Neil article was to "demonstrate the sophisticated and collaborative literacy desirings of children when they are given time, space, materials, and permission to create multimodally" (p. 315).  In VTS, there is an emphasis on visual literacy, where "through the acts of viewing, responding, and visually representing during the prewriting phase" (p. 28).

In Neil's classroom, Tara had to be thoughtful in her planning and know her curriculum expectations well so that she could be more flexible and embrace the unexpected ways her students created their stories.  Tara began by putting out lots of different materials for writing, then witnessed the children "intra-acting-with-materials," while in VTS (during the discussions), there are carefully sequenced visual art images that engage and sustain learners.  From observation (in the Kuby article), the authors noted that the children were not always "intentional and/or sure about what they were creating" with their wide variety of materials.  "At times, Tara stepped in and shared examples from previous years or from her own experiences, so a child who needed more prompting had a range of options to consider" (p. 316),  while in VTS, the teacher stays neutral without contributing information or insight into dialogue.  Discussions are facilitated, not directed in VTS, much like the peer conversations in the Kuby article.  However, main questions are focused and repeated in VTS to keep the conversation moving and new ideas forming from one piece of artwork.

Neil's creations were fissures that departed from "expected ways of being."  For instance, experiences with Neil's inventive personal narrative game demonstrates that "the writing process or cycle is not always linear" (p. 319), as we discussed in class on the 11th.  An interesting question is then posed: how do I, as a teacher, embrace fissures in my teaching plans?  Do I allow freedom from "proper" and "conventional" techniques as both articles showcase?  Do I allow individual interpretations as an "additional avenue for understanding and responding" (p. 29)?

Lastly, I thought it was interesting that both articles discussed allowing the exploration of aggression and conflict (in these cases, among boys) within the classroom environment.  I have always struggled with knowing how to address these types of output with students, and it makes sense that students need space to "bring in pop culture and their experiences outside of school even if they are steeped with violence and injustices" (p. 323) and it motivates their passions and provides them with opportunities to share their interests with others, like the partnership between Neil and Zane.
We have to trust that children need time to play with materials so they can create for themselves, but also teach others how to use materials in various ways as well...as the VTS article mentions, these are ways to stimulate "literacy achievement in ways that more common instructional approaches do not" (p. 28).  This type of play leads to a positive self-efficacy within students because they are experimenting with their own ideas and it is leading them to thinking that they might not otherwise apply.  They are taking risks, persevering through tough choices and using their peer relationships to expand their ideas even further.

No comments:

Post a Comment