Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Five Minds for the Future by Howard Gardner



Howard Gardner writes in his book Five Minds for the Future that “there are certain kinds of minds people will need if they—if we—are to thrive in the world during eras to come” (page 1).  These minds have each been important throughout time and each can continuously be developed in our students and ourselves.  The five minds are the disciplined mind, the synthesizing mind, the creative mind, the respectful mind, and the ethical mind.  Each mind has differences, but each can, and should, overlap in order for one to become a well-rounded individual.

The disciplined mind relates to the intellect of a person, one who has studied at least ten years and has mastered at least one way of thinking.  Because this is a more scholarly approach to learning, the vernacular must be honed in a particular subject. A disciplined individual, therefore, masters key literacies enabling them to build upon previously learned information and encourage them to continue to develop their research in areas that interest them.  In the art classroom, a disciplined mind can be developed by practicing technical skills and offering historical information about art and artists.

A person with a synthesizing mind “takes information from disparate sources, understands and evaluates that information objectively, and puts it together in ways that make sense” (page 2).  Gardner states that there are eight types of synthesis: narratives, taxonomies, complex concepts, rules and aphorisms, powerful metaphors (as well as images and themes), embodiment without words, theories, and metatheory.  This mind helps prove that actual learning has taken place in students by allowing them to teach what they have been taught.  It shows the transference of information happening within the classroom.   Specifically, in the art classroom, an individual with a synthesizing mind would develop multiple and diverse visual representations to embody an idea in their personal artwork as well as interpret big ideas and questions posed by other artists in their work.

Using the two prior minds, the creating mind, according to Gardner breaks new ground.  He states that without relevant disciplines, it’s not possible to be creative, but creativity goes above rehearsing the status quo as one would do if focused solely on a particular discipline.  While the synthesizer’s goal is to explain what has already been established in a useful way, the creator’s goal exceeds that by extending knowledge beyond the contours of a genre, and guides their own learning to unanticipated directions.  The creator is dissatisfied with what is current in his or her work, standards, questions, and answers.  Creators like marching to the beat of their own drums.  They try and try again because they open themselves up to failure instead of fearing it in order to take risks and make new, different marks on the world.  Luckily, creativity is honored, so it is emphasized in various areas of our society.  As art educators, we must recognize the importance of “going beyond class requirements to pose new questions” (page 156).  We are challenged to “keep alive the mind and sensibility of the young child” (page 84).  As Picasso once declared, “I used to draw like Raphael; it has taken me my whole life to learn to draw like a child” (page 84).  We must cultivate creativity through authentic lessons wherein meaning can be made and students have the opportunity to share their work in order to receive feedback for growth.

While the first three minds are important in order to succeed individually, without the respectful mind to welcome differences amongst peers, a person will flounder in the outside world.  A respectful person seeks to understand other cultures and listens to the opinions and virtues of another to have the ability to work with others toward a common goal.  Strategies for this mind in the art classroom are prevalent.  Art educators can have students view artifacts and visual images from other cultures and use Visual Thinking Strategies and critiques in order to learn to engage in respectful dialogue with one another.  As educators in general, we should be cognizant of the way we are modeling respectful relationships amongst different groups.

Lastly, the ethical mind “ponders the nature of one’s work and the needs and desires of the society in which one lives” (page 3).  The ethical mind bounces off of the respectful mind in a more abstract way by conceptualizing “how workers can serve purposes beyond self-interest and how citizens can work unselfishly to improve” (page 3).  An educator’s role is vastly important in developing this mind because of the fact that children are spending more of their waking hours at school than anywhere else.  As with the respectful mind, modeling is important in fostering the ethical mind in students.  Students want to be a part of a structured classroom where they are part of the rule-making process.  Showing students that fairness, truthfulness, loyalty, and integrity are important in the art classroom will encourage them to use ethical rules outside of the classroom.

These five minds are immensely important because they “span both the cognitive spectrum and the human enterprise” (page 3).  To facilitate the development of these minds, we must attempt to understand resistances our students might encounter and figure out ways we can offer support and be role models in the development of their five minds.  Gardner concludes by saying “an education system is not worthy of its name unless its representatives can clearly articulate what that system is striving to achieve and what it seeks to avoid or curtail” (page 166).  It’s up to us to set examples for our students and our communities, so we must also be engaging in the process of living with the five minds at the forefront of our teaching.

No comments:

Post a Comment