Tuesday, June 3, 2014

Blog Reflection Day 1: Debating Visual Culture in Art Education

In her article Rescuing Art from 'Visual Culture Studies,' Michelle Marder Kamhi starts off with a bang by saying that adding visual culture studies into art education is akin to treating the Nike of Samothrace and Michelangelo's David on par with Barbie and Ken.  She argues that "the main emotions inspired by the Visual Culture approach are all on the side of anger, resentment, and moral outrage, leaving little place for such feelings as love, pride, compassion, admiration, tenderness, courage, grief, hope, honor, reverence, or joy" and that the latter feelings are often "stifled by the detached, analytical approach adopted in Visual Culture Studies."

In one of the more appalling sections of her article, Kamhi even goes so far as to essentially say photographs cannot be considered true works of art because "while one assumes that everything about a painting is the result of choices made by the artist, one can never be sure, in looking at a photograph, which aspects were selected as important or meaningful by the photography, and which were accidental or incidental."  She states that in order for something to be considered a work of art, the artist must feel a personal connection to their subject and that connection should convey meaning through depictive and expressive means versus through symbols.  It can be readily argued, however, that many photographers specifically choose subject matter based on the personal connection to their subjects and also that many painters convey meaning through symbols.  Kamhi maintains that "teachers who emphasize the need to help students "decode" images place an undue emphasis on symbolic content" and that the qualities that make something a work of art, such as in Jan van Eyck's The Arnolfini Portrait, are the "natural" aspects of its subject matter; the sober facial expressions, the gesture of their joined hands.  In my opinion, this argument by Kamhi is very contradictory, because understanding these qualities about a painting is very similar to decoding.  Especially when discussing artwork with young students, these associations with body language and facial expressions are the most easily recognized and therefore "decoded."

Paul Duncum's article Seven Principles for Visual Culture Education contrasts Kamhi's views by stating that we are in need of principles for contemporary curriculum which coincide with the world we are currently living in.  He feels that while "early 20th-century elements and principles remain important" they are only "one way to consider the formal qualities of images."

Duncum lists seven principles for examining imagery, whether they be considered fine art or pop culture.  The principles are Power, Ideology, Representation, Seduction, Gaze, Intertextuality, and Multimodality.  Using these principles, students are able to gather their own meaning while looking at art and advertisements...basically all imagery that surrounds and bombards them on a daily basis.  These principles enable students to gather meaning from the world they live in and make associations and connections to artwork they may not otherwise have an understanding of.

Isn't this type of knowledge more important for our students to possess than the outdated views expressed by Kamhi?  Our students can't make associations about paintings from the past until they understand the cultural contexts of their own world.  Not allowing students to learn to appreciate and make their own meaning from all types of artwork would probably appall the artist's Kamhi mentions in her article.  And their peers that she disregards (abstract artists) would, I imagine, wholeheartedly disagree that their implications haven't been understood when people come to museums to view their work.  Art cannot possibly fit into the narrow category that Kamhi describes, and we must facilitate open discussions with our students using Duncum's principles to help them understand that artwork goes beyond a well-painted representation and is more than meets the eye.

No comments:

Post a Comment