In chapter 5, the authors explore four traditions in the practice of education in the US which are progressive, conservative, radical, and spiritual. I, like most people in this class, don't find myself relating to one of these traditions, but rather a combination of them on any given day.
On the progressive path, teachers "save our schools by attending to those who truly matter--our kids" (location 1364). At the core of progessive teaching is "a commitment to creating powerful and meaningful connections between the student and the curriculum" (location 1364). John Dewey stands out as a leader of this tradition because of his criticism of "mindless memorization and forced repetition." He and his followers fight for meaningful learning opportunities and the engaging of students in enlivened activities. Critics of the progressive path say that students aren't gaining skills necessary to prepare them for college or beyond, that it is coddling students rather than challenging them. The section on progressive teaching ends with the story of Emilie who is frustrated that her actual teaching experience is quite different from her student teaching experience. It seems to me that this can sometimes be the problem with student teaching...that it isn't an accurate representation of what is going to happen when you're in the classroom every day with the same students. When you're trying things out for a few weeks, then moving on to your next assignment. I think student teaching can create a kind of honeymoon world for everyone involved, and when you're actually in your real-life classroom, you have to deal with discipline issues you may not have encountered...you have to deal with this new pace of life, this marathon of months and months of teaching without the advice of your supervising teacher, that person looking over your shoulder guiding you along the way. The advice Emilie received was that she should either ignore her "theoretical fancies" or "trust her progressive methods." Two very different sides to the coin flip. I'm not sure taking the either/or route is in Emilie's best interest. If I were in Emilie's shoes, and I feel like all educators can be at any given time during the school year, I would consider a more disciplined structure with this particular class, but continue to nurture as she has in the past.
Next, the authors discuss the conservative approach. E. D. Hirsch is mentioned as being a tireless defender of this approach with a "core knowledge" and "cultural literacy" stance to education. It seems his ideals are at the forefront of educational politics today, where advocacy of a "carefully sequenced core curriculum" is touted as "the only known way of ensuing that all the students in a classroom will be sufficiently familiar with the context of classroom discourse" (location 1464). His structure relies on direct methods and is discipline-bound. Many in the educational community feel that Hirch and Michael Oakeshott, another purveyor of the conservative viewpoint, are making inequalities and divisions more powerful, but the conservatives themselves feel that the educational potential within the human inheritance must be reckoned with. The section concludes with the story of Steven, who decides to teach at a KIPP school, which is devoted to rigorous college-prep, but tends to fail students who are in need of academic and personal support. It seemed that Steven needed more from from teaching than the conservative approach could provide. He sought to engage with his students in a more progressive way. Looking at Steven's teaching trajectory, he may need to rethink his tenure with KIPP and seek a school where he doesn't feel like he has wasted time trying to enliven the experience of his students with intrigue and wonder.
I see the third agenda, one where social justice rules, somewhat as a combination of the two prior approaches, but is probably closer to the progressive end of the spectrum. George Counts believed that teachers should "find a way to help society serve the needs of those who created most of the value in society--the workers and common American citizens" (location 1544). He and other proponents of social justice attempt to "ensure that all students, especially poor urban students of color and impoverished white rural youth, gain the skills required to access more complex jobs in our information based society" (location 1559). Social justice in the eyes of Lisa Delpit strives to maintain "the importance of attending to the needs of poor students of color" (location 1566) by recognizing good teaching and the brilliance of poor, urban children and building on these children's strengths. However, other social justice approaches focus on "issues of privilege and antibias" (location 1579). Also, in social justice teacher education programs, preparation includes being capable of understanding and educating all children with various inequalities. "As educators," the authors write, "we yearn for a world that is basically just and fair and offers all students the promise of rich and powerful learning" (location 1593).
The fourth tradition is one that makes an educational experience sacred and gives it spiritual dimensions. Dwayne Huebner, an author "living and learning in the spiritual realm," thinks of education as a journey in which students and teachers pose and discuss life questions and focus on having meaningful encounters rather than mastering curriculum in the traditional way. He depicts teaching as a "calling from our depths to serve others" (location 1651). He says that "when teachers examine the educational landscape we should see what is there and hear the call to respond with love, truth and justice" (location 1659). This leads to an approach where contemplation and reflection are paramount. Critics concerned with the spiritual domain feel that it is "indistinguishable from religious understandings...and neither ill-defined nor vague religious beliefs ought to be supported in schools" (location 1688). This section ends with the story of Sophie, a tale I could relate most to of the four. As I have mentioned in previous weeks, I'm at a stage in my teaching where I feel overwhelmed with carrying struggles other than my own and my patience is running thinner than usual. I kind of think of this class as a way to center myself weekly and focus on the importance of my career, much like the retreats Sophie attended. I look at reflection and spirituality as a way to breathe deeply, slow down, take it all in. Search for deeper meaning in all areas of life. I truly think this is a skill that we need to teach children so that they can find joy in whatever they do, and I definitely think it has a place in schools, even though it can be tricky to define it without parents automatically assuming that the school is trying to indoctrinate their children with religion.
In the sixth and final chapter of Reflective Teaching, the authors discuss self, student, and context: what the role of the teacher's self is in teaching, what it means to serve our students, and how our role in community contexts enhance or restrict our students' futures.
The engagement of a teacher depends on how they view themselves. "Some view teaching as work, others as a profession, and still others see teaching as more akin to a vocation, a "calling" (location 1718). Parker Palmer, an author I am glad to be familiarized with through this class, believes that "self-knowledge, an enhanced understanding of the inner lives we bring into the classroom, is elemental and central to...what it means to be a good teacher" (location 1782). "Good teachers," he is quoted as saying, "join self, subject, and students in the fabric of life because they teach from an integral and undivided self" (location 1791). When I think about my teaching self, I know I have my faults (see above), but I hope that for the most part the self I bring to the classroom is the one that looks for the good in any situation and tries to turn negative feelings into positive ones, both in myself and my students. What perturbs my teaching self is the sweating of the seemingly small stuff, both from my students and my colleagues. Something I know I'm guilty of as well, but I'm trying my hardest to work on, especially this year. My teaching self delights in seeing personal challenges met by my students. The joy that radiates from them when this happens, ripples to me (as I will discuss in my metaphor project from last week if I can ever finish writing it!!) and makes any bad day turn immediately around.
The next section focuses on attending to students. The authors first point out that a look back on educational policies of the past show a focus on subject matter coverage instead of on students. In recent years, student achievement has come to the forefront of education, but critics (and most educators) maintain that the efforts are too focused on test scores than with what students are actually learning. I suppose a good outcome of focusing on test scores is that it helps pinpoint students who are struggling and gives teachers an idea of what in particular is a challenge to that particular student. Another way of attending to students is by incorporating an awareness of their social and emotional needs, therefore enabling them to develop "fundamental skills for life effectiveness" like "recognizing and managing our emotions, developing caring and concern for others, establishing positive relationships, making responsible decisions, and handling challenging situations constructively and ethically" (location 1851). Lisa Delpit's beautiful quote about listening to alternative points of view and putting our beliefs on hold harkens back to the previous chapter about being spiritual and sort of out-of-body in order to "learn what it might feel like to someone else" (location 1895) and is probably, for me, the most important part of being a teacher.
The final section of this chapter takes into consideration the context of schooling. The importance of examining the social conditions of schooling seems to be waning, the authors write, in order to train teachers for their work but not necessarily to prepare them for teaching. Attending to the "social conditions of schooling reemphasizes the need to acquaint prospective and practicing teachers with the various ways in which these social, political, and cultural dynamics may affect the educational process" (location 1931). Context counts, y'all. In my teaching work environment, as in most others I'm sure, the social conditions change every year, and I am glad I was taught to be aware of them so that I can emphasize attention where it is most needed: with students who are on plans, with students who have disabilities, and with students who have come from difficult backgrounds. For me, I don't see these particular social conditions as ones that obstruct my efforts, but instead I see them as opportunities to attend more to those students that are in need. This brings us to the next subsection of context, which is engaging community and difference. While "creating communities in which trust and difference coexist is a rare achievement in our educational spaces...creating that trust amidst significant difference" can be challenging" (location 1989). We can do this by, as our buddy Parker Palmer writes, understanding we are in this crazy thing together, developing an appreciation of "otherness," cultivating "the ability to hold tension in life-giving ways," generating personal voice within, and strengthening "our capacity to create community" (location 2011).
One last case study is discussed, that of Sylvia, who has become sort of disenchanted with teaching over the years. Well, not teaching, but the race...no...dead sprint of chasing that "elusive edge" of achievement. I think every time I read one of these vignettes that I identify most with that particular one, but I really think Sylvia's case is spot-on for my feelings this past year. I want my day to be about the play involved in making art, I want it to be about the beauty of creation. I'm trying to figure out how to do this while still meeting standards, grade card guidelines, goals set by various improvement teams around the district, etc. I'm trying to figure out how to spark interest and encourage students who seem apathetic and uninterested in coming to school. If Sylvia is anything like me (and I feel like she is), the nature of her attention to her students is pure and good-intentioned, and there's no such thing as caring too much. "While teaching taxes us, it also rewards us 10 times over" (location 1693). I am rewarded 10 times for the little things that give me headaches (that f#&*ing small stuff, again!! D'oh!!), the things that I am challenged by. I am rewarded more than I am taxed. What a gift and blessing! That's more than almost anyone in any profession can say. That's my new mantra. What I have to keep telling myself to get over my hump.