Monday, April 21, 2014

Week 4: Visual Metaphor

I apologize for this being so late, guys.  These last few weeks have been the cray-cray cherry on top of my insane sundae of a year, and I'm trying to dig out of the hole of obligations I created for myself.

Speaking of metaphors...

Week 4's project dealt with creating a visual metaphor based on the idea that our classrooms are living, breathing organisms.  I immediately thought that the best metaphor for my classroom would be that it and the many organisms that make it up are like a prism.  I had been thinking about this concept since week 1 when Michelle Livek added this fantastic quality of being a great teacher to her list: being a prism.  She wrote, "we should take in the light and intellect that our students offer up to a situation and then become a prism, by which that light is reflected back to them in a beautiful spectrum of color. We can show/introduce their strengths to them, and help them to see how amazing they really are."  W-O-W.  I couldn't stop thinking about this idea and how it related to the quote by my late ceramics professor from undergraduate, Russel Schmaljohn, about teaching art.  He said, "Teaching is a reciprocal enterprise.  It is co-conspiratorial.  When students are learning, so is the teacher."  So I set out to create a visual piece that represented the way our (mine and my students) individual lights reflect and refract, change and create new colors, shapes, feelings, and ideas, when we work together.  

I had so many thoughts going through my mind before I started working on this project.  I thought first about the materials I would use.  I knew I wanted something transparent to show multiple layers, something to mimic a ripple, or light bouncing from one surface to the next.  My bachelor's degree is in painting, so I knew I could layer washes of watercolors or watered down acrylics, but I wanted to go for something else.  I had a lot of tissue paper scraps sitting around and began playing with them, letting them lay where they fall.  This wasn't creating quite the effect I was hoping for.  I was remembering back to some paintings I had seen on a trip to NYC a few years ago.  I don't remember the name of the artist, but I had taken a few images:


The second image is cropped down and is really the composition that ultimately inspired my piece.

To add to this idea, I had recently been to an art opening of abstractions by KC's Warren Rosser and loved the geometry in his pieces:


A combination of the two ideas was formed in my head, and I set to work.

I have a bulletin board in my classroom that is about 50"x70".  I had recently taken down an old chart, and I re-covered it with a yellow piece of craft paper.  I then started cutting the tissue paper into 9x10 inch rectangles, then cut them in half diagonally.  I cut an entire stack of colors down, not exactly knowing which I would use.

I played around with various thumbnails on the computer wanting to find a pleasing gray-scale template that flowed from dark to light, mimicking the light shattering that I discussed above.  Once I picked one, I began laying the colored triangles into an arrangement that had similar contrast:


After rearranging multiple times, I made my final decision and carefully stapled each piece on my bulletin board:



I liked the look of the piece this way, but felt adding another layer would convey the message of the prism better.  I cut more rectangles, this time 8x9, and then cut those into smaller triangles.  I used the same layout as before, but I omitted a column on the right, and opted to leave out the black triangles, as not to darken the piece any further, and to leave open-ended edges to represent future growth:


The final piece creates a pleasing shift of colors and shapes that, to me, represents the ways multiple ideas and personalities (both mature and childlike), can work together in harmony to create new, previously unrealized ideas.  The delicacy of the medium, and the way the pieces are barely tacked in place represents the way these ideas can easily be shifted in a new direction and be built upon over and over, learning and growing infinitely.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Week 7: Read and Reflect

Confession alert: my friends, I have never read Olivia Gude prior to this week.  Heck, I didn't even know who she was, which was slightly awkward during last summer's class when people would mention her and everyone would nod knowingly, and I would nod knowingly, and mmmm hmmmm, and smile all like, "I got this, people" when I was really like, "I DO NOT got this, people."  Point being, I'm glad that I'm finally "getting to know" her through her writings.

Right off the bat in the first reading (Playing, Creativity, Possibility), Gude states that "we must question the assumption that any art project will cultivate creative behaviors and then develop projects whose methods support core objectives for quality creativity curriculum" (page 31).  Entering the grad program at MU has really made me question my teaching methods.  I feel like my very traditional upbringing in the art education field is being challenged, in the best way possible.  But there's still that strict, principles and elements side of me that can't give up control in my classroom in order to give students complete access to their creative souls.  In Act 1, Anxiety, Gude delves further into the minds of dispirited students...MY students...by saying that they struggle because they "don't know how to judge what kind of solution will be acceptable. [They don't] even consider that the final product might be personally meaningful" (page 32).  Hey, wake-up call!!!

And just when I think she couldn't be talking to me directly to me more than she already is, we come to Act 2: Resistance, where Gude writes that a teacher must be aware of why her student's feel discomfort in engaging in artistic processes.  I love that she mentions paradoxically "lightening up" and "getting serious" at the same time (page 32).  As an art teacher, I have to be the one to show my students that it's okay to dream, to play, but that they still have to work, work, work, just like they would at anything they do.

In Act 3: Cultivating Creativity, Gude lists conditions that might inhibit student's creativity: "self-consciousness in front of peers, over-scheduling that doesn't leave time for daydreaming, hours spent immersed in passively watching TV or actively playing video games, schools that focus on getting the one right answer, and a society that judges success on standardized test scores and the size of bank accounts" (page 33).  I can definitely see these things affecting my students, which could account for some of the feet dragging I've seen with them this year more than ever.  I feel like I need make the time (though there is little of it) to ensure students are getting a meaningful experience from art and "take seriously the responsibility for what they say and make" (page 34) so that they can grow to be more confident and less worried about being self-conscious when working creatively. "Conditions of psychological safety and freedom that make creativity possible are produced, not merely by the teacher's wishes, but rather by how his or her attitude manifests itself" (page 34).

The projects that Gude describes, based on Spiral Workshop, help students become willing to jump into experimenting creatively then consider what they've made and if a "sustained artistic investigation" is worthwhile.  This is very much how I was taught in my undergraduate drawing and painting classes; here are perimeters to get you started, see where they take you.  It seems so daunting and uncomfortable when I think about doing this with my very young students, especially in the classes where my numbers hover around 30.  I'm uncomfortable because I think that they will be confused and lost, and I'll want to help them without giving them answers (makes me think back to Abba Felix), but this isn't the way they've been learning, so the discomfort will trickle down and AHHHHHH!  But I can't live in this scared limbo when I know what needs to be done...and I know how the finding of answers through creative process will help them grow as free-thinking individuals that "produce surprising, useful, stimulating results" (page 37).

This discussion leads nicely into the next reading by Gude, New School Art Styles: The Project of Art Education.  Gude writes that the basic building block of art curriculum, "the art project," is often product-based, and does "not actually support creative self-expression and...[is] not effective in teaching students about methods of artmaking outside of school contexts" and that, "we must be willing to let go of some of the old familiar projects (and their myriad variations) in order to make room for other sorts of projects and other kinds of art experiences" (page 6).

Gude discusses the suggestion that art teachers should give their students the freedom to pursue their own creative endeavors.  I'm personally glad that she mentions the fact that "most students today could not initially make good use of this sort of freedom" and that "it is not realistic to assume that most art classes in school settings can function as open studios" (page 6).  While I would love for this to be the case, I feel like it is my job as an elementary teacher to introduce the foundations of art to my little ones and show them ways to experiment with a variety of materials.  Without some sort of guidance, I think parents, administrators, and my colleagues would value my program less and less if it seemed like I wasn't teaching anything.  Where is this self-depreciating talk coming from?  It's been one of those weeks.  And I think this leads me to admit what the main inhibitor of my creative development really is...I'm never feel quite sure I'm going to "get it right."  What if the free-thinking project I come up with doesn't help my students learn the GLEs and district standards and my job is at stake because of it?  Worse, what if the kiddos feel so frustrated by it, they start to hate coming to art?  Talk about a bleak outlook...why am I so scared of this concept?  Because it's new?  Because I've never seen this type of teaching in action?

The ideas Gude presents make the idea of helping students engage "in authentic processes over making facsimiles" less intimidating and help me realize that I'm headed in the right direction/already teaching this way somewhat.  I also appreciate that she eases some of my worries by saying it's okay to be "skeptical of an art projects' current worth and non-judgmental of your own past choices and pleasures" (page 13).  I have to broaden my thinking and be willing to use my experience combined with the experience of my students, and use the changes in culture that will undoubtedly happen to strengthen my curriculum for the betterment of my students.

In the last article by Gude, Postmodern Principles: In Search of a 21st Century Art Education, the author starts by essentially saying that strictly using the formal 7 + 7 is outdated and bland.  I'm coming around to the idea, I AM, but again, it's hard to deny my formal roots...and reconsider the thinking that the littles that I work with need more structure than such open planning can give them?  I'm not there yet.

The criteria of the Spiral Workshop on page 8 helps garner my support for this 21st century thinking, however.  "Curriculum based on generative themes that relate to the lives of students and their communities" is something I definitely facilitate within my classroom already, and I feel like I use "art as investigation" frequently.  The criteria I would like to work on is creating a more studio-esque atmosphere where artmaking is led by my students and their diverse conceptual insights.  Gude follows the list from the Spiral Workshop by describing her list of eight "important postmodern artmaking practices," which are: appropriation, juxtaposition, recontextualization, layering, interaction of text & image, hybridity, gazing, and representin'.  More amazing ideas that I know my students would love and be able to translate in their own individual ways!  Specifically, I want my students to do more with layering, especially in digital media, and recontextualization, which would help them see ways they can associate various meanings into their art.  I already do sprinkle some of these into my lessons, sort of "postmodern artmaking lite" but I could definitely use these new ideas to make my curriculum relevant to the future needs of my students...enabling them to better "participate in and shape contemporary cultural conversations" (page 13).

Sunday, February 23, 2014

Week 5: Responses

Response to Erika's post: Erika, as I read through your post, I kept thinking about how many of the same feelings I am having this year.  That after seven years of teaching, I'm still not quite sure how to describe my teaching self.  That I go back and forth between traditions on any given day.  And unfortunately, that even with my much younger students, I'm seeing some entitlement and apathy that is frustrating to overcome.  But it's those students that have the drive and unending, pure joy from creating that help keep us motivated to find ways to crack the tough shell of the former category.

Reflection: Until I read Erika's post this week, I hadn't quite realized how much I also feel like a broken record with my constant musings of feeling stressed.  "Stressed" is such a nondescript word but it's the first that comes to mind when I take inventory of my thought process throughout each day.  I'm on a hamster wheel this year that keeps turning and going faster and faster.  I'm not sure it's moving in the right direction, but I hope by the end of this class I might figure out if I need to stop and reevaluate, go the opposite direction, or hop off and start fresh.

Response to Karen's post: I, like Amy, was really struck by your comment about filling vessels.  We have to get to know our students in order to better understand what their needs are.  It's a little intimidating to think that these are all very different needs, but I think we as art educators have the greatest chance of individualizing our responses to guide students because the world of art is so varied.  "If we understand ourselves as stewards of wonder, curiosity, self-confidence, and the unquenchable thirst for knowledge, we must speak directly to the human hearts of each individual student."  What beautiful thinking, Karen!!

Reflection: I'm reading all these wonderful, succinct reflections on the readings this week (like Karen's) and I can't help but feel that I'm worrying too much, and dodging actual answers to questions.  Through reading these reflections though I really am enlightened and feeling more positive and ready to start my work week after a sort of rough last week.  #rallytime

Week 5: Read and Reflect

In chapter 5, the authors explore four traditions in the practice of education in the US which are progressive, conservative, radical, and spiritual.  I, like most people in this class, don't find myself relating to one of these traditions, but rather a combination of them on any given day.

On the progressive path, teachers "save our schools by attending to those who truly matter--our kids" (location 1364).  At the core of progessive teaching is "a commitment to creating powerful and meaningful connections between the student and the curriculum" (location 1364).  John Dewey stands out as a leader of this tradition because of his criticism of "mindless memorization and forced repetition."  He and his followers fight for meaningful learning opportunities and the engaging of students in enlivened activities.  Critics of the progressive path say that students aren't gaining skills necessary to prepare them for college or beyond, that it is coddling students rather than challenging them.  The section on progressive teaching ends with the story of Emilie who is frustrated that her actual teaching experience is quite different from her student teaching experience.  It seems to me that this can sometimes be the problem with student teaching...that it isn't an accurate representation of what is going to happen when you're in the classroom every day with the same students.  When you're trying things out for a few weeks, then moving on to your next assignment.  I think student teaching can create a kind of honeymoon world for everyone involved, and when you're actually in your real-life classroom, you have to deal with discipline issues you may not have encountered...you have to deal with this new pace of life, this marathon of months and months of teaching without the advice of your supervising teacher, that person looking over your shoulder guiding you along the way.  The advice Emilie received was that she should either ignore her "theoretical fancies" or "trust her progressive methods." Two very different sides to the coin flip.  I'm not sure taking the either/or route is in Emilie's best interest.  If I were in Emilie's shoes, and I feel like all educators can be at any given time during the school year, I would consider a more disciplined structure with this particular class, but continue to nurture as she has in the past. 

Next, the authors discuss the conservative approach.  E. D. Hirsch is mentioned as being a tireless defender of this approach with a "core knowledge" and "cultural literacy" stance to education.  It seems his ideals are at the forefront of educational politics today, where advocacy of a "carefully sequenced core curriculum" is touted as "the only known way of ensuing that all the students in a classroom will be sufficiently familiar with the context of classroom discourse" (location 1464).  His structure relies on direct methods and is discipline-bound.  Many in the educational community feel that Hirch and Michael Oakeshott, another purveyor of the conservative viewpoint, are making inequalities and divisions more powerful, but the conservatives themselves feel that the educational potential within the human inheritance must be reckoned with.  The section concludes with the story of Steven, who decides to teach at a KIPP school, which is devoted to rigorous college-prep, but tends to fail students who are in need of academic and personal support.  It seemed that Steven needed more from from teaching than the conservative approach could provide.  He sought to engage with his students in a more progressive way.  Looking at Steven's teaching trajectory, he may need to rethink his tenure with KIPP and seek a school where he doesn't feel like he has wasted time trying to enliven the experience  of his students with intrigue and wonder.

I see the third agenda, one where social justice rules, somewhat as a combination of the two prior approaches, but is probably closer to the progressive end of the spectrum.  George Counts believed that teachers should "find a way to help society serve the needs of those who created most of the value in society--the workers and common American citizens" (location 1544).  He and other proponents of social justice attempt to "ensure that all students, especially poor urban students of color and impoverished white rural youth, gain the skills required to access more complex jobs in our information based society" (location 1559).  Social justice in the eyes of Lisa Delpit strives to maintain "the importance of attending to the needs of poor students of color" (location 1566) by recognizing good teaching and the brilliance of poor, urban children and building on these children's strengths.  However, other social justice approaches focus on "issues of privilege and antibias" (location 1579).  Also, in social justice teacher education programs, preparation includes being capable of understanding and educating all children with various inequalities.  "As educators," the authors write, "we yearn for a world that is basically just and fair and offers all students the promise of rich and powerful learning" (location 1593).

The fourth tradition is one that makes an educational experience sacred and gives it spiritual dimensions.  Dwayne Huebner, an author "living and learning in the spiritual realm," thinks of education as a journey in which students and teachers pose and discuss life questions and focus on having meaningful encounters rather than mastering curriculum in the traditional way.  He depicts teaching as a "calling from our depths to serve others" (location 1651).  He says that "when teachers examine the educational landscape we should see what is there and hear the call to respond with love, truth and justice" (location 1659).  This leads to an approach where contemplation and reflection are paramount.  Critics concerned with the spiritual domain feel that it is "indistinguishable from religious understandings...and neither ill-defined nor vague religious beliefs ought to be supported in schools" (location 1688).  This section ends with the story of Sophie, a tale I could relate most to of the four.  As I have mentioned in previous weeks, I'm at a stage in my teaching where I feel overwhelmed with carrying struggles other than my own and my patience is running thinner than usual.  I kind of think of this class as a way to center myself weekly and focus on the importance of my career, much like the retreats Sophie attended.  I look at reflection and spirituality as a way to breathe deeply, slow down, take it all in.  Search for deeper meaning in all areas of life.  I truly think this is a skill that we need to teach children so that they can find joy in whatever they do, and I definitely think it has a place in schools, even though it can be tricky to define it without parents automatically assuming that the school is trying to indoctrinate their children with religion.

In the sixth and final chapter of Reflective Teaching, the authors discuss self, student, and context: what the role of the teacher's self is in teaching, what it means to serve our students, and how our role in community contexts enhance or restrict our students' futures.

The engagement of a teacher depends on how they view themselves.  "Some view teaching as work, others as a profession, and still others see teaching as more akin to a vocation, a "calling" (location 1718).  Parker Palmer, an author I am glad to be familiarized with through this class, believes that "self-knowledge, an enhanced understanding of the inner lives we bring into the classroom, is elemental and central to...what it means to be a good teacher" (location 1782).  "Good teachers," he is quoted as saying, "join self, subject, and students in the fabric of life because they teach from an integral and undivided self" (location 1791).  When I think about my teaching self, I know I have my faults (see above), but I hope that for the most part the self I bring to the classroom is the one that looks for the good in any situation and tries to turn negative feelings into positive ones, both in myself and my students.  What perturbs my teaching self is the sweating of the seemingly small stuff, both from my students and my colleagues.  Something I know I'm guilty of as well, but I'm trying my hardest to work on, especially this year.  My teaching self delights in seeing personal challenges met by my students.  The joy that radiates from them when this happens, ripples to me (as I will discuss in my metaphor project from last week if I can ever finish writing it!!) and makes any bad day turn immediately around.

The next section focuses on attending to students.  The authors first point out that a look back on educational policies of the past show a focus on subject matter coverage instead of on students.  In recent years, student achievement has come to the forefront of education, but critics (and most educators) maintain that the efforts are too focused on test scores than with what students are actually learning.  I suppose a good outcome of focusing on test scores is that it helps pinpoint students who are struggling and gives teachers an idea of what in particular is a challenge to that particular student.  Another way of attending to students is by incorporating an awareness of their social and emotional needs, therefore enabling them to develop "fundamental skills for life effectiveness" like "recognizing and managing our emotions, developing caring and concern for others, establishing positive relationships, making responsible decisions, and handling challenging situations constructively and ethically" (location 1851).  Lisa Delpit's beautiful quote about listening to alternative points of view and putting our beliefs on hold harkens back to the previous chapter about being spiritual and sort of out-of-body in order to "learn what it might feel like to someone else" (location 1895) and is probably, for me, the most important part of being a teacher.

The final section of this chapter takes into consideration the context of schooling.  The importance of examining the social conditions of schooling seems to be waning, the authors write, in order to train teachers for their work but not necessarily to prepare them for teaching.  Attending to the "social conditions of schooling reemphasizes the need to acquaint prospective and practicing teachers with the various ways in which these social, political, and cultural dynamics may affect the educational process" (location 1931).  Context counts, y'all.  In my teaching work environment, as in most others I'm sure, the social conditions change every year, and I am glad I was taught to be aware of them so that I can emphasize attention where it is most needed: with students who are on plans, with students who have disabilities, and with students who have come from difficult backgrounds.  For me, I don't see these particular social conditions as ones that obstruct my efforts, but instead I see them as opportunities to attend more to those students that are in need.  This brings us to the next subsection of context, which is engaging community and difference.  While "creating communities in which trust and difference coexist is a rare achievement in our educational spaces...creating that trust amidst significant difference" can be challenging" (location 1989).  We can do this by, as our buddy Parker Palmer writes, understanding we are in this crazy thing together, developing an appreciation of "otherness," cultivating "the ability to hold tension in life-giving ways," generating personal voice within, and strengthening "our capacity to create community" (location 2011).  

One last case study is discussed, that of Sylvia, who has become sort of disenchanted with teaching over the years.  Well, not teaching, but the race...no...dead sprint of chasing that "elusive edge" of achievement.  I think every time I read one of these vignettes that I identify most with that particular one, but I really think Sylvia's case is spot-on for my feelings this past year.  I want my day to be about the play involved in making art, I want it to be about the beauty of creation.  I'm trying to figure out how to do this while still meeting standards, grade card guidelines, goals set by various improvement teams around the district, etc.  I'm trying to figure out how to spark interest and encourage students who seem apathetic and uninterested in coming to school. If Sylvia is anything like me (and I feel like she is), the nature of her attention to her students is pure and good-intentioned, and there's no such thing as caring too much.  "While teaching taxes us, it also rewards us 10 times over" (location 1693).  I am rewarded 10 times for the little things that give me headaches (that f#&*ing small stuff, again!! D'oh!!), the things that I am challenged by.  I am rewarded more than I am taxed.  What a gift and blessing!  That's more than almost anyone in any profession can say.  That's my new mantra.  What I have to keep telling myself to get over my hump.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Week 3: Read and Reflect


The first thing that struck me in the text Reflective Teaching: An Introduction, was this quote from the series preface by authors Zeichner and Liston, "we are educators first, realists second, and dreamers third" (location 144--okay, quick explanation for the location instead of page number before you read completely through my musings this week, I downloaded my texts to my Kindle app on my computer and for some books it won't give me a page number but a location.  If anyone knows how I can switch that or find the page number, please let me know!)  I think this quote is a good, simple break down of how I can begin to realign my priorities in order to become a more reflective teacher.


Moving on to chapter 1, which gives us a "distinction between reflective and technical approaches to teaching" and highlights "some of the current issues connected to reflective teaching," I was very interested in the first scenario with Rachel and thought it was very similar to issues I have within my classroom currently, specifically with the behavioral problems that arise when students have time to make decisions for themselves.  Always before I feel like I focused, like Rachel, on what happens after the students cause problems, not how to stop the problems from happening in the first place by looking at differentiating/restructuring my own teaching.  To become a more reflective teacher, I must “think both about how [I] frame and then how to solve the problem at hand” (location 390).

A question that made me go "hmmm" in this chapter is the first from the "On Reflective Teaching" section: Has/did your own teacher education program prepare(d) you to be the kind of teacher who questions the educational goals and the classroom and school contexts and who plays an active role in creating and critiquing curriculum and who considers a variety of instructional strategies?  The authors write, and I couldn't agree more, that “teachers should be active in formulating the purposes and ends of their work, that they examine their own values and assumptions, and that they need to play leadership roles in curriculum development and school reform” (location 390-396).  I feel lucky that, as I've mentioned previously, I didn't go about getting certified in the traditional manner with practicum hours and student teaching.  I strongly believe that obtaining my degree in art, then getting right into the classroom while taking education classes has enabled me to become a teacher who thinks on my feet fairly quickly and not be afraid to try various methods of instruction to find what works for me and my students.  Doing versus watching it being done.  But I was very disillusioned by many facets, or should I say many teachers, of the traditional education department at my undergraduate university.  I'm not saying the program is bad, it just didn't work for me.   

As for the curriculum aspect of the question, I am pretty much in charge of creating my own curriculum for my classes.  Sure I have GLE guidelines, but there isn't one Liberty Art Curriculum that defines how each elementary art teacher in the district has to teach to a "t."  I'm not being told what I can and can't do by people who aren't in my classroom on a daily basis.  I just had a Braveheart moment there where I pictured myself as Mel Gibson riding through my classroom on a horse, shouting to my students, "they can take our lives, but they'll never take our FREEDOM!!"  

That being said, I always need guidance and I always need reminders to take time reflect on educational goals I have set for my classroom, so this program and this class specifically couldn't come at a better time for me.  Especially in my seven year itch period.  Wasn't that one of Picasso's periods as well?  Ha!  I'm getting punchy after all these days inside, you guys...

Back to discussing the fact that I plan my own curriculum.  Shouldn't more educators have that ultimate control over their own processes and therefore products?  “It is time for the educational research community to recognize, and take into account, the issues and the knowledge of teachers and others who work in schools” (location 407).  Our district has good intentions of allowing its teachers to ultimately decide, but they could be better.  But they have government officials to answer to as well.  Top-down and all that.  The professional development meetings at my school are often led by teachers, which seems progressive, but are they just “conduits of other’s ideas” as the book suggests?  Also, the programs that teachers are using for teaching the core subjects are constantly changing, not because our teachers have expressed the need, but because of the research based solutions that are valued as the “key to educational improvement.”  I'm afraid the teachers at my school aren't able to give these programs time to make a difference....that they are constantly being forced to move on to whatever is being touted as the “next best thing.”  “The process of understanding and improving one’s own teaching must start from reflection on one’s own experience” (location 419) and often teachers aren't given a chance to reflect, much less have their own experience.

I find it interesting that at the end of the first chapter, the authors discuss the misunderstanding  of what it is to be a reflective teacher.  They beg the questions, “is any thinking about teaching that teachers do reflective teaching? Is any action a teacher takes supportable, just because he or she has thought about it in some systematic way?” (location 451).  I am instantly reminded of the professional development led by teachers in our school which I mentioned above.  At the end of these meetings, I leave feeling like we haven’t accomplished a darn thing.  Are we reflecting somewhat on issues we have had with this or that?  Yes.  But are we brainstorming actual solutions or ways we can adapt and/or change our current ways of thinking?  I’m afraid not.  Is this, in turn, creating a culture of complainers?  Are we taking our "reflections" only as far as articulating the problems we are experiencing?  I am sure I’m not the only teacher who gets bogged down by the “teacher’s lounge talk” or “parking lot conversations” I hear about the issues within public education.  The more we talk about these issues, the greater they become, therefore seeming impossible to surmount.

In chapter 2, the authors discuss Dewey’s belief that “in every school there exists one or more taken-for-granted definitions of reality or a “collective code” in which problems, goals, and the means for their accomplishment become defined in particular ways, e.g., this is the way we do things at our school” (location 475).  It is often difficult for people to hear criticism, even if it’s constructive.  I definitely think a lot of teachers, including myself at times, have a hard time hearing things they need to change, revaluate, reflect on.  But why, when it’s the only way we can truly grow? 

“When we reflect about students in our classrooms, we need to listen to and accept many sources of understanding” for it can only help create a more holistic place to learn.  The authors mention, however, that it is important to keep some routines in place because “routine is necessary to keep our lives manageable” and “some sort of balance needs to be achieved between our reliance on and our examination of those assumptions and routines that guide us daily” (location 547). 

The authors then discuss Dewey's ideals to becoming a reflective teacher.  One is openmindedness.  “An individual who is openminded does not attempt to hold the banner for one and only one perspective” and “accepts the strengths and limitations of distinct ways of looking at students, learning, and schooling” (location 503).  Another is responsibility which “has to involve reflection about the unexpected outcomes of teaching because teaching, even under the best of conditions, always involves unintended as well as intended outcomes” (location 515).  We have to ask ourselves if the results of our teaching are good, for whom, and in what ways.

A few other items that really resonated with me this week:

Wouldn’t it be nice if more people viewed “teachers as educational leaders who can learn from others, and even take direction at times, but in the end who are not subservient to those removed from the classroom” (location 558).

“Reflective teachers are fallible teachers” but they are “unabashedly committed to the education of all of their students and to their own education as teachers” (location 531).

And finally: "The process of learning to teach continues throughout a teacher's entire career" which goes back to the quote by my mentor Russ Schmaljohn from week 1: "Teaching is an interactive reciprocal enterprise.  It is co-conspiratorial.  When students are learning, so is the teacher."

Sunday, February 2, 2014

Week 2: Read and Reflect

Right off the bat in the Parker Palmer reading, I was struck by the statement that, "the ethos of too many classrooms [is] destructive of community" (33-34).  It is sad but true that most teachers spend a lot of time talking and only a little time allowing students to grow and be "mind-independent."  I wish I could say I made that up, but I definitely had to Google objectivism in order to read other perspectives on the philosophy.  I don't know if I've ever had a teacher that completely adhered to an objectivist perspective on teaching.  My best teachers allowed me figure things out and grow on my own.  But they also guided me by offering advice, suggesting readings...not so that I would have one opinion or the other, but so that I could see both sides and make an educated decision. 

I think we all strive to be teachers like Abba Felix.  But not necessarily in the literal sense.  His story is rich and thought-provoking, but I have to agree as a student myself that it would be incredibly frustrating for students who have always been taught in a more "traditional" manner, to have a teacher not give them any feedback whatsoever.  Yes, eventually very driven students would find their own path to the truth they were seeking.  But I think a great teacher's job is to facilitate learning and open doors to possibilities they have had the years to experience.  To be a guide to the truth.

But again, as the text mentions, this conventional way of teaching exists because it has simplified our lives.  As products of this conventional education, are we like Abba Felix's students who "wanted words instead of life, reports instead of reality, words that would create the illusion of life while relieving them of responsibility for living it, words of authority on which they could rely and retire"(42)?  

The story of Abba Felix "has a timeless and universal quality.  It reveals problems in education that are little changed today.  It tells of students who are resistant to truth, of a teacher who is frustrated with them, of the breakdown of community in teaching and learning" (46).  This statement resonates with me so much.  Because I teach at the elementary level and my husband teaches at the college level, we often compare stories about the detrimental effects current educational practices (both inside and outside the home) are having on our students, young and old.  Frustration runs high when answers aren't provided, and giving up or waiting for someone else to figure something out seems to be the first response when something doesn't work out according to original plans.  As a teacher, I could never stay mum and watch my students flounder, especially when they are so young and sensitive.  But I also never want to be a hinderance to experimentation and trying new ways of finding answers.  I don't want to be a teacher who gives answers, but I do want to be a teacher who is an ally in finding paths that can lead to answers.

In chapter 3 of Marzano, we were tasked to set growth goals.  Marzano has been a reoccurring figure both in my art education studies and in my professional development at school.  This chapter suggests preparing for the year by by conducting a self-audit, then selecting two or three areas to focus on improving over the course of the year.  These should be elements the teacher has scored low on and elements in which the teacher is interested in improving.

When I looked through the Teacher Scales for Reflection in the appendix, I find that a lot of the questions can be sort of lumped together.  When I see kids 50 minutes once a week, I want them to spend time and focus on their process and progress.  I try not to spend too much time talking about the goals of the piece, or tracking things formally because I like to see where my students will make connections on their own.  We have open discussions with plenty of friendly controversy (respectful disagreements about what is going on in a piece of artwork, or what they appreciate most about artwork we are looking at) and I try to manage response rates effectively, but that can be hard when we are rushed for time.  I continuously walk around informally taking note and tracking to make sure students are engaged, so I would rate myself at a 2 or 3 in those areas.  For something like celebrating success, I would score myself high: 3 1/2.  I feel like in the art room, in those precious moments we have together each week, we are always celebrating something someone has accomplished.  As far as establishing and maintaining rules and procedures, we have pretty much the same routine every year, so we model it and practice it at the beginning of each semester and when needed.  Students know the cues and signals I use as reminders, so I would rate myself around a 3, but I would rate myself low (1) on applying consequences for lack of adherence to rules and procedures.  This doesn't happen often, but when it does, I don't think I follow through very thoroughly.  The general layout of my classroom has clear traffic patterns and students are physically moving to get supplies when needed, etc, but since it is kind of cluttered at times and because I don't often change out bulletin boards within the classroom I would rate myself at 1 or 2, as I did on the 12 qualities survey last week.  I would rate myself higher, 3 or 4 probably, in areas involving engagement with my students because of my passion for teaching and my ability to maintain effective relationships with them.  This is similar to the score I would have given myself on the 12 qualities survey.  When introducing new material and critical information, I go back to what I mentioned about goals.  I place importance on main ideas and ask about correlating information we've learned in the past, but these discussions are often brief and I rely on the work students are creating to tell me if they're learning, so I guess I would be around a 2.

If I were to pick a couple of goals I would like to work on, they would be raising my score from 1 to 3 on number 34. What do I typically do to apply consequences for lack of adherence to rules and procedures?  I feel like I quickly redirect students well if they aren't adhering to rules, but I often don't follow up properly, as mentioned above, so the student might not actually learn from the the situation, but rather forget about it.  This doesn't help prepare them properly for making good choices in the future.  I would also like to work on going from a 1 to a 3 on number 26. What do I typically do to manage response rates?  Again, this can be hard to do when I'm so crunched for time, but it is important not to rush a student into giving an answer.  I want my students to be able to describe what they are thinking thoroughly.  This type of answer gives students perspectives aside from my own, and helps them understand there's not one way of determining an answer for a lot of questions.

Overall, I think I'm doing pretty well, staying around a level 3, but I would like to work on becoming a more innovative thinker to change things up and keep things interesting on a daily basis for my students.

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Week 1: Responses

Response to Adair's post: I also scored myself low for organization, but I think it's interesting that you mentioned organization might mean something different to all people, Amy.  The more I reflect on it, I think I was scoring myself low because of how walking into my room and seeing my piles might look to an outsider.

Adair, your educational history is very similar to mine in that I mostly have art educators thus far, with the exception of my mother.  I wonder if it's because as artists ourselves, we tend to suround ourselves with like-minded people...

Reflection: Another thought I had after I posted this response to Adair is that we might remember our art teachers more because we have them multiple years most of the time.  In a small school setting, you might have an art teacher from Kindergarten all the way through till you graduate.  Even though you don't see your art teachers every day, they are watching you grow each year and creating a stronger bond with you than you might have with someone who teaches you only one year.

Response to Michelle Livek's post: #13...AMAZING!  I think it goes along with the quote I have on my Education Tree, that you mentioned (which, btw, is a quote by my professor Russ...my college had a retrospective of his work when he retired from teaching and that was an answer he gave to an interview question when he was asked about his many years there).  I think being a prism also means letting their light reflect back to us and learn from our students.  Too often, when we're caught up in the fast pace of the day, we don't take the time to think about what our students are teaching US!  And to show them how awesome we truly think they are and how much they're teaching us is soooo important!  Being a prism is something I need and want to work harder on every day.

Reflection: The quote I mentioned is this one by my late mentor/friend Russell Schmaljohn: "When someone would ask me what I taught, I would reply, I teach people (or students). "No, I mean what subject?" Art, I replied.  I could have said work, work habits, obsessive behavior, or problem-solving to name a few.  "Art? What kind of art?"  OK, I teach ceramics mostly.  I teach all of the ceramics classes; I teach a lot of beginning drawing; and I have taught some art education courses, freshman seminar and some other stuff.  "Teaching is such a fulfilling, rewarding activity.  You must be so proud"...I never could identify with this vicarious success syndrome; like when I'm hungry, I don't feel fulfilled and nourished by watching somebody eat.  I never got my rest by putting the kids to bed and then watching them sleep, too.  Teaching is an interactive reciprocal enterprise.  It is co-conspiratorial.  When students are learning, so is the teacher."  This is such a truthful statement, yet again, I think I get so caught up in the daily grind, I forget to think about everything my students are teaching me along the way.  Hopefully this class will help me remember to stop and smell the roses, so to speak.  :)