Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Week 7: Read and Reflect

Confession alert: my friends, I have never read Olivia Gude prior to this week.  Heck, I didn't even know who she was, which was slightly awkward during last summer's class when people would mention her and everyone would nod knowingly, and I would nod knowingly, and mmmm hmmmm, and smile all like, "I got this, people" when I was really like, "I DO NOT got this, people."  Point being, I'm glad that I'm finally "getting to know" her through her writings.

Right off the bat in the first reading (Playing, Creativity, Possibility), Gude states that "we must question the assumption that any art project will cultivate creative behaviors and then develop projects whose methods support core objectives for quality creativity curriculum" (page 31).  Entering the grad program at MU has really made me question my teaching methods.  I feel like my very traditional upbringing in the art education field is being challenged, in the best way possible.  But there's still that strict, principles and elements side of me that can't give up control in my classroom in order to give students complete access to their creative souls.  In Act 1, Anxiety, Gude delves further into the minds of dispirited students...MY students...by saying that they struggle because they "don't know how to judge what kind of solution will be acceptable. [They don't] even consider that the final product might be personally meaningful" (page 32).  Hey, wake-up call!!!

And just when I think she couldn't be talking to me directly to me more than she already is, we come to Act 2: Resistance, where Gude writes that a teacher must be aware of why her student's feel discomfort in engaging in artistic processes.  I love that she mentions paradoxically "lightening up" and "getting serious" at the same time (page 32).  As an art teacher, I have to be the one to show my students that it's okay to dream, to play, but that they still have to work, work, work, just like they would at anything they do.

In Act 3: Cultivating Creativity, Gude lists conditions that might inhibit student's creativity: "self-consciousness in front of peers, over-scheduling that doesn't leave time for daydreaming, hours spent immersed in passively watching TV or actively playing video games, schools that focus on getting the one right answer, and a society that judges success on standardized test scores and the size of bank accounts" (page 33).  I can definitely see these things affecting my students, which could account for some of the feet dragging I've seen with them this year more than ever.  I feel like I need make the time (though there is little of it) to ensure students are getting a meaningful experience from art and "take seriously the responsibility for what they say and make" (page 34) so that they can grow to be more confident and less worried about being self-conscious when working creatively. "Conditions of psychological safety and freedom that make creativity possible are produced, not merely by the teacher's wishes, but rather by how his or her attitude manifests itself" (page 34).

The projects that Gude describes, based on Spiral Workshop, help students become willing to jump into experimenting creatively then consider what they've made and if a "sustained artistic investigation" is worthwhile.  This is very much how I was taught in my undergraduate drawing and painting classes; here are perimeters to get you started, see where they take you.  It seems so daunting and uncomfortable when I think about doing this with my very young students, especially in the classes where my numbers hover around 30.  I'm uncomfortable because I think that they will be confused and lost, and I'll want to help them without giving them answers (makes me think back to Abba Felix), but this isn't the way they've been learning, so the discomfort will trickle down and AHHHHHH!  But I can't live in this scared limbo when I know what needs to be done...and I know how the finding of answers through creative process will help them grow as free-thinking individuals that "produce surprising, useful, stimulating results" (page 37).

This discussion leads nicely into the next reading by Gude, New School Art Styles: The Project of Art Education.  Gude writes that the basic building block of art curriculum, "the art project," is often product-based, and does "not actually support creative self-expression and...[is] not effective in teaching students about methods of artmaking outside of school contexts" and that, "we must be willing to let go of some of the old familiar projects (and their myriad variations) in order to make room for other sorts of projects and other kinds of art experiences" (page 6).

Gude discusses the suggestion that art teachers should give their students the freedom to pursue their own creative endeavors.  I'm personally glad that she mentions the fact that "most students today could not initially make good use of this sort of freedom" and that "it is not realistic to assume that most art classes in school settings can function as open studios" (page 6).  While I would love for this to be the case, I feel like it is my job as an elementary teacher to introduce the foundations of art to my little ones and show them ways to experiment with a variety of materials.  Without some sort of guidance, I think parents, administrators, and my colleagues would value my program less and less if it seemed like I wasn't teaching anything.  Where is this self-depreciating talk coming from?  It's been one of those weeks.  And I think this leads me to admit what the main inhibitor of my creative development really is...I'm never feel quite sure I'm going to "get it right."  What if the free-thinking project I come up with doesn't help my students learn the GLEs and district standards and my job is at stake because of it?  Worse, what if the kiddos feel so frustrated by it, they start to hate coming to art?  Talk about a bleak outlook...why am I so scared of this concept?  Because it's new?  Because I've never seen this type of teaching in action?

The ideas Gude presents make the idea of helping students engage "in authentic processes over making facsimiles" less intimidating and help me realize that I'm headed in the right direction/already teaching this way somewhat.  I also appreciate that she eases some of my worries by saying it's okay to be "skeptical of an art projects' current worth and non-judgmental of your own past choices and pleasures" (page 13).  I have to broaden my thinking and be willing to use my experience combined with the experience of my students, and use the changes in culture that will undoubtedly happen to strengthen my curriculum for the betterment of my students.

In the last article by Gude, Postmodern Principles: In Search of a 21st Century Art Education, the author starts by essentially saying that strictly using the formal 7 + 7 is outdated and bland.  I'm coming around to the idea, I AM, but again, it's hard to deny my formal roots...and reconsider the thinking that the littles that I work with need more structure than such open planning can give them?  I'm not there yet.

The criteria of the Spiral Workshop on page 8 helps garner my support for this 21st century thinking, however.  "Curriculum based on generative themes that relate to the lives of students and their communities" is something I definitely facilitate within my classroom already, and I feel like I use "art as investigation" frequently.  The criteria I would like to work on is creating a more studio-esque atmosphere where artmaking is led by my students and their diverse conceptual insights.  Gude follows the list from the Spiral Workshop by describing her list of eight "important postmodern artmaking practices," which are: appropriation, juxtaposition, recontextualization, layering, interaction of text & image, hybridity, gazing, and representin'.  More amazing ideas that I know my students would love and be able to translate in their own individual ways!  Specifically, I want my students to do more with layering, especially in digital media, and recontextualization, which would help them see ways they can associate various meanings into their art.  I already do sprinkle some of these into my lessons, sort of "postmodern artmaking lite" but I could definitely use these new ideas to make my curriculum relevant to the future needs of my students...enabling them to better "participate in and shape contemporary cultural conversations" (page 13).

1 comment:

  1. Hi Ashley!

    Wonderful reflection, I could hear the gears turning in you head as I read.
    One thing Ive noticed over the years in this discussion of transcending the elements and principles, is that many think that means abandoning them all together. I think really its simply reframing the emphasis. You can't build a house with out a hammer. The hammer is the tool..... (the elements) If we only look at the hammer and make sure its in our hand just right and that it can hammer all kinds of nails, big, small, use it fast or slow, the house (meaning) never gets built. If we focus on the house instead, the hammer supports the growth and development of the house. :) as the house builds.
    This process is of course relative depending on the age group, its a relative balance of emphasis. The thing about littles is they are so full of thrilling ideas that as soon as we suggest there might be a specific way to use that hammer, their ideas get squeezed into that "method" rather than exploring the idea with abandon while adapting the hammer to the idea.... (Its early, I hope this is making as much sense to you as it is to me right now.. perhaps another cup of coffee....)
    Your reflection on this is right on. Gude offers lots of great thought on the topic and I agree, there is no reason to feel bad about anything you've (or anyone has) done to date. Your reflection is packed with insight and the willingness to examine. "The Great Room" of any house. :)

    ReplyDelete