Thursday, June 20, 2013

Blog Topic #5 (continued): Pink's Introduction and Play

In the introduction to his book A Whole New Mind, Daniel Pink introduces his readers to the Conceptual Age: an era where artistic-brained people will prove to be a major asset to the forward movement of businesses, and in our case, schools. 
  
Pink first discusses the old view of the differences between the left side (or crucial side) of the brain versus the right side (or subsidiary side) of the brain.  He mentions that it was Caltech professor Roger W. Sperry who first brought to light the realization that the right hemisphere could reason, recognize patterns, and interpret emotions and nonverbal expressions.  Taking note of these ideas, and showing the art world how the right brain could be used effectively, was Dr. Betty Edwards with her book Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain.  I have always loved this quote by Dr. Edwards: "Drawing is not really very difficult.  Seeing is the problem" (15).  While, as Pink mentions, her techniques are thought to be a bit oversimplified, I agree with the notion that you must quiet the left brain in order to better visually comprehend and interpret the whole picture with your right brain.  Pink maintains that the two hemispheres ideally work best together, whether in physically controlling the body, or in processing, understanding, or analyzing information.    

Next, Pink breaks down the three main reasons being art-minded is so important in this Conceptual Age: Abundance, Asia, and Automation.  First, because the previous Information Age produced such a high standard of living, we live in an incredibly abundant world where we own more, hoard more, and waste more.  But is this abundance making us happy?  Not according to Pink's research.  He finds that though prosperous, our country still yearns for "beauty and transcendence" (36).  Second, Pink discusses the influence Asia has on the Conceptual Age.  He states that "today's knowledge workers" will have to "command a new set of aptitudes" and that "they'll need to do what workers abroad cannot do equally well for much less money" (39).  Employers will be looking for people that can forge relationships, tackle challenges in creative ways, and synthesize the big picture.  The third topic Pink discusses as an integral reason for the shift to a more conceptual way of thinking is Automation.   Whereas "last century, machines proved they could replace human backs," "this century, new technologies are proving they can replace human left brains" (44).  Unless professionals develop those creative, right brain aptitudes that "computers can't do better, faster, or cheaper", their services will be rendered nil (47).

Pink proposes that the answer to preparing ourselves for the Conceptual Age is by mastering six aptitudes that are high-concept and high-touch.  One of those aptitudes is Play.  

Brian Sutton-Smith is quoted as saying, "The opposite of play isn't work.  It's depression.  To play is to act out and be willful, exultant and committed as if one is assured of one's prospects" (187).  As art teachers, we know what the business world is finally catching on to: that play inspires creativity and collaboration, and that it enhances satisfaction, therefore leading to greater productivity.  In my classroom, I try to facilitate this type of playful atmosphere.  In the future, I hope to introduce more projects in which students can collaborate, invent, game, and joke.  I loved that in the Portfolio section of this chapter, Pink suggests to businesses scheduling their staff retreats at an elementary school so that employees can take in children's uninhibited joy and exploration.  

I enjoyed the Play discussion thoroughly, especially watching Tim Brown's TED video in which he gives examples of the relationships between creative thinking and play.

http://www.ted.com/talks/tim_brown_on_creativity_and_play.html
  
His discussion inspired me to try some of these ice-breakers with my staff and students on the first few days of school to help them unself-conciously surrender themselves to creative ideas and interaction.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Blog Topic #5: Teaching Students of the Conceptual Age

We've thus far learned the "whys" about discussing visual culture with our students.  We know that because our society is in constant flux, we either have to go with the flow and try new methods of teaching that contain contemporary problems and solutions, or we're going to get dragged under by the current.  The readings from Friday tell us how we can manage this challenge using a more modern form of art curriculum.

In Freedman's words, curriculum "is a form of social action" (106).  While including visual culture can be a challenge, she believes we must reconceptualize our current ideals (in which technical aspects are of utmost importance) to focus on the cultivation of ideas, imagination, and style.  She mentions that curriculum theorist Patrick Slattery thinks that because curriculum is created by people who leave parts of themselves within said curriculum, it should focus on issues of self, because that is where learning takes place.  If we put ourselves into lessons, our kids will undoubtedly follow suit because, per Freedman, "students are active learners and construct individual meaning from experience" (127).

With the Common Core standards currently being pushed so heavily in our schools, this type of curriculum only makes sense.  It's a perfect way to show administrators that the art classroom is an invaluable part of a school structure: that our lessons contain problem solving, ways to improve literacy comprehension, and encompass various cross-curricular subjects.  Eisner mentions in Chapter 6 that "when the teacher's perspective is one that might be called emergent rather than prescriptive, the stakes for pedagogical innovation are higher and the demands greater."  We, therefore, hold the key to unlocking our student's highest potential.

But again, how can we achieve this?  In the article The Visual Literacy White Paper, written by Dr. Anne Bamford, the author lists various strategies we can use to promote visual literacy in our art classrooms, like: exposing students to a variety of interesting images and having thoughtful discussions regarding the images; discussing the intention of images that have been used throughout history; and experimenting with a variety of computer-generated media.  These are great examples of the "inquiry-based methods of instruction" mentioned by Freedman and they "are particularly appropriate for studying contemporary imagery" (127).

Monday, June 10, 2013

Blog Topic #4: The Social Life of Art

Previous to last Thursday, I didn't have much knowledge of gaming.  The most time I'd ever spent really considering this aspect of visual culture was during Visual Literacy and Visual Culture this past Spring and, because the subject wasn't broached in depth, if you'd asked me point-blank if I thought gaming was a "Fine Art"-form, I would have been hesitant to answer.  My thoughts about the media have solidified upon reading Eisner, Freedman, Thomas and Seely Brown, and listening to Paola Antonelli discuss the MoMA's recent acquisition of fourteen video games.  I've always found video games visually appealing...but I didn't really "get it".  Antonelli herself states in the TED video that she never claimed video games were ART; she instead calls it "interaction design."  So what's the argument?

Antonelli's justification for the acquisition is that the museums job is to tackle popular culture, but to tackle it as something that has to be researched.  The research criteria involved figuring out how to exhibit the pieces and how to preserve it for future generations, among other things.  In Freedman's Chapter 5, "The impact of contemporary imagery has generated a wide range of sociopolitical and economic issues, including its influence on student identity, notions of citizenship, beliefs about democracy, and so on" (94).  Antonelli's research and development of the MoMA collection brings to the surface the idea that, to paraphrase Eisner in Chapter 5, we must understand these forms of art as cultural artifacts that both reflect and affect the culture in which they appear.   

Arguments and controversies will constantly arise over what is and what is not art.  Could part of this be a breakdown in communication from art teachers to their students?  The bottom line with visual culture like technology and especially video games, is that "children use play and imagination as the primary sense of their new and rapidly evolving world" (from A New Culture of Learning).  Eisner proposed in Chapter 5 that, "arts education programs not only pay attention to the forms of thinking that make sensitive and imaginative imagemaking possible, that they not only cultivate the forms of perception that enable students to read the qualities of the visual world, but also promote students' abilities to describe those qualities intelligently."  If we don't evolve with these forms of culture, we're going to get left behind.  Or worse, leave our students behind.    

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Blog Topic #3: What Is Art And What Should We Be Teaching?

Transmediation, or, using various forms of media to respond to cultural texts, has been a reoccurring idea posed in my last couple of graduate classes.  Why?  As Semali and Fueyo write in their article, "because students are bombarded by multimedia" and we as teachers, "need to find methods and analytical frameworks that help students make sense of and critique the codes and coded messages of our times."

So how, as Freedman discusses, do we go about finding appropriate "connections between contemporary visual culture and the past" so that students can "develop an understanding of the complexity of their visual world"(43)?  She mentions that we must research the context and quality of the visual culture we are presenting to students.  But who determines what form of art is worth teaching?

In our class discussion today, we touched on the age-old question "what is art?"  A question that might never have a solid answer.  While we can't offer certain answers to students, what we can offer them (and what Freedman stresses in her third chapter) is an opportunity to form context that is meaningful to them by way of introducing various forms of visual culture.  I reiterate from my previous post that deconstructing these texts using Visual Thinking Strategies is a paramount tool in our modern curriculum to help us contextualize learning, or, "to help students understand that many conditions influence judgments of goodness and that those judgments are made based on the relationship of these conditions" (Freedman 54).

Back to transmediation, a way of ensuring the quality of learning that Freedman discusses, is to introduce artwork that connects our students to the culture that surrounds them: work that uses multiple literacies and ties into modern culture such as graphic novels, video games, movies, and music: work that is interactive, such as the sculptures of Richard Serra.  According to the review of his MOMA retrospective, and based on my own interactions, Serra's work creates a transmedial experience.  His work is best appreciated by physically interacting with it: walking into and around the pieces.  I always find that his work gives me the feeling of vertigo.  In the review, one participant describes his experience with the work as disorienting,  and created a feeling where "awe and fear mingle(d) with pleasure" (Kimmelman 1).

Coincidentally, I went to see the Serra retrospective in New York in 2007 when it first opened up and snapped a few pictures:




Blog Topic #2: Examining Beliefs About Art

The Eisner Chapters (3 and 4), discuss the teaching practices of successful art teachers, and how these practices can positively effect students.  He states at the end of Chapter 3 that "the art room affords students an opportunity to develop their persistence, to explore their individuality, to share what they have learned with others, and to learn from others what they themselves do not yet know."  After teaching for six years, I feel I have gained understanding about practices Eisner discussed that have worked well for me and my students.  Specifically, I would say my strengths lie in my technical craftsmanship, my rapport in providing supportive feedback after reading the quality of my student's work, and my ability to make "connections between earlier and current work and between current work and the world outside the classroom."  Something Eisner mentioned that I would like to work on would be not getting stuck in my habits and get too comfortable with my routine.  I have found that if a project turns out well with my students one year, I have had a tendency in the past to use it over and over.  While I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing in certain ways, I can see that in doing this, I'm making other mistakes that Eisner touches on in Chapter 3: for instance, I'm concerning myself more with making a product instead of checking that the content students are engaging in is valuable.  By changing my routines next year, I can ensure content is fresh, that students are learning more because of the personal meanings they are making, and that their comments are relevant when discussing the aesthetics of work they see or have created.    

Which leads me to the Freedman Chapter: Finding Meaning in Aesthetics.  Freedman states on page 23 that "definitions of aesthetic response, the conditions of aesthetic experience, descriptions of aesthetics objects, and aesthetic theorizing are at the foundation of curriculum." As I mentioned above, when working with my students, I need to monitor their aesthetic understanding of their own work and the art that relates to it.  I can do this through the practice of Visual Thinking Strategies.  The practice of VTS relates so perfectly with a selection from Freedman's conclusion in which she states, "meaning is inherent to aesthetic experience, and in contemporary visual culture and aesthetic theory interested interpretations are not only expected, but promoted" (41-42).

As for Barrett, in About Art Interpretation for Art Education, he mentions in his conclusion that,

individual interpretations can broaden the community's understanding of a work of art.  Those individual interpretations can also broaden our knowledge of one another. Communal interpretations can inform individual interpretations, causing individual interpreters to reflect more, consider further.  A multiplicity of interpretations can unify rather than divide a group of individuals, helping them form a community of understanding, a community that values diverse beliefs about art and life. (18)

This statement kind of synthesizes the main ideas I gathered from the three authors this evening.  It also makes an even stronger case for pulling myself out of my routines a bit in order to use Visual Thinking Strategies in more of my classes. Using VTS, I will be able to delve further into the aesthetics of the visual culture in my classroom.

Thursday, May 9, 2013

Blog Topic #11: Preparing for Teacher's Choice


The Sunflower Quilting Bee at Arles (1991) -Faith Ringgold
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_l267nyD5yI1qzy9rqo1_500.jpg

I have decided to stick with my original image for the Teacher's Choice VTS lesson after reviewing and reexamining the prospective images I chose a few weeks ago.  I have chosen this image because of the reasons I listed in my blog post from week 9 and because I still think this is an appropriate image for their age, stage, interests, and abilities.  I also still think the features/aspects I listed in week 9 will be points of interest that they will take notice of and that will intrigue them during our discussion.

This image is a good choice for the content/curriculum I am currently teaching because it is full of many of the Principles and Elements of Art I have discussed with them since Kindergarten, so they can make connections there.  The piece also references several time periods in history.  One of the fourth grade GLEs states that students can "compare art from historical time and culture", so this will be a good piece to align with that particular standard.  Students will be able to use their knowledge of history from their classroom to decode what is going on and who the famous figures in the piece are.  I'm hoping the piece will challenge the students to do what I stated above: discuss their knowledge of these historical figures and the traditions of African American culture that are depicted in the piece.

Blog Topic #10: Video 2--Lesson 4/Image 1

Here is the link to my second video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ew0og-Iqo_g&feature=youtu.be

  • Student Engagement Learning:
    • Students continue to be very willing and excited to participate in VTS discussions, as evident by the many hands that raised in the air even before silent looking time was over.
    • Observations made by my students during this discussion:
      • Some students were immediately under the impression that the photograph had been taken during times of segregation because of the separation between the group in the foreground and the man in the background, and because of seemingly old-fashioned attire.  They were a bit fixated on the thought that the African American man in the background looked very sad, and that lead some of them to believe the people in the foreground may have been slave owners.  I wasn't expecting students to speak so frankly about the subject (especially the second child that participated), and I was a little flustered when I tried to paraphrase his comments.
      • Other students thought the clothing looked like it belonged in present times, specifically the child that was wearing what appeared to be track pants/sweatpants.  I thought that was an interesting observation.  Several students thought the people were traveling because of the setting of the piece. 
    • I had a feeling the students had recently been reading about or studying times of segregation in their classroom lessons, due to the connections they were making to the photograph.  Due to their connections to previous knowledge, I think I would qualify them between the Stage I category because their observations are still very centered on the emotions of the piece, and the Stage II category for this discussion, because of their desire to build a framework for the piece using "their own perceptions...and the values of their social, moral and conventional world".
    • Students are definitely expressing their observations conditionally, because they start many of their sentences with "It looks like..." or "It might be...".
    • There were definitely demonstrations of more flexible thinking during this lesson because several students raised their hands more than once to give multiple viewpoints of the work, changing their minds from their first observation as they listened to other's opinions. 
    • Students are linking their own responses by agreeing and continuing with thoughts their classmates have stated, or by coming back to their own responses and building upon them.  They have been very respectful with each other, often agreeing with ideas their peers have had.  When there are disagreements, they are made kindly and without being hurtful.
    • I think I did an okay job altering the questions this time.  It will be good to have more practice getting myself out of the habit of just asking the three questions the original way.
    • Students are continuing to grow with VTS, learning how to look for details that make connections to information they are learning about in their regular classrooms and world outside of school.
    • Specifically the many observations about slavery this week led me to believe my students had been discussing in their classroom and it was fresh in their minds when they looked at the image this week.
  • Reflective Practice:
    • This VTS lesson was not my best.  I was concerned about my time this week, and the addition of my new introduction and the need to vary questions this week made me get a little jumbled at times.  Plus, at the beginning, I thought the computer had stopped recording and I got flustered.  Technology....bleh.  ;)
    • The original three questions and the prescribed teacher behaviors are what I do feel confident in this week.  I feel like it was just the new stuff I was struggling with.
    • I don't think rewording the questions impacted the goal of the lesson, I just think I wasn't as smooth with their delivery as I will be with more practice.  I had gotten into a good groove of using the original three, and I was obviously trying to remember to vary them this week, leading to me stumbling over my words at times.
    • I was very surprised at the fact that my students discussed slavery so much with this image, simply because of the separation between the white family and the African American man in the background.  I was concerned about how to paraphrase the second boy's final comment, because of it's insensitive frankness.  I don't think he meant for it to be that way, but in any event, I struggled with paraphrasing.  On the VTS homepage, it suggests to immediately follow with "What more can we find?" to encourage other opinions to be expressed.  I will definitely keep this in mind if I run into a situation like this in the future.
  • Planning:
    • For future VTS lessons, I will memorize my introduction by practicing it in my spare time for several days and I will become better at varying the questions so my transitions aren't as choppy in the future by practicing doing so with a group of peers or a different group of students.