Antonelli's justification for the acquisition is that the museums job is to tackle popular culture, but to tackle it as something that has to be researched. The research criteria involved figuring out how to exhibit the pieces and how to preserve it for future generations, among other things. In Freedman's Chapter 5, "The impact of contemporary imagery has generated a wide range of sociopolitical and economic issues, including its influence on student identity, notions of citizenship, beliefs about democracy, and so on" (94). Antonelli's research and development of the MoMA collection brings to the surface the idea that, to paraphrase Eisner in Chapter 5, we must understand these forms of art as cultural artifacts that both reflect and affect the culture in which they appear.
Arguments and controversies will constantly arise over what is and what is not art. Could part of this be a breakdown in communication from art teachers to their students? The bottom line with visual culture like technology and especially video games, is that "children use play and imagination as the primary sense of their new and rapidly evolving world" (from A New Culture of Learning). Eisner proposed in Chapter 5 that, "arts education programs not only pay attention to the forms of thinking that make sensitive and imaginative imagemaking possible, that they not only cultivate the forms of perception that enable students to read the qualities of the visual world, but also promote students' abilities to describe those qualities intelligently." If we don't evolve with these forms of culture, we're going to get left behind. Or worse, leave our students behind.
Ashley, you're absolutely right about how teacher's communicate "what art is" to their students. It might not resonate as much with younger students, but in high schools and at universities a teacher or professor's views on what is art and what is not can absolutely change/shape a students views. Instead of telling my students what is art and what is not, I would like to be able to teach them how to intelligently make those decisions on their own.
ReplyDeleteAshley, I also come from a background lacking knowledge of the world of gaming. I had never considered the games to be art until that day in class after the discussion. I think that it's important to recognize art & design. And without a doubt, it takes years of designing to create such an elaborate interactive experience.
ReplyDelete