Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Blog Topic #12: Video 3--Teacher's Choice

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n16ppg0fOZY


  • Reflecting on Yenawine's article on image selection, I believe my Teacher's Choice image was an appropriate choice for my students because of it's accessibility and potential for narratives, and because of it's emphasis on culture and history.
  • I think the image challenged them just right.  They are still getting the hang of VTS, but they seemed very comfortable opening up and discussing their ideas about the meaning of the piece.  One challenge that they surprisingly avoided was discussing who they thought the African American women might be, with the exception of one student mentioning that Rosa Parks could be one of the female figures depicted.  I think this was probably because they weren't confident enough in their historical knowledge to specifically name any of the females, or discuss their achievements.    
  • This seemed to be one of their best sessions as far as picking out details I hoped they would notice.  They were very intrigued by the repetition between the sunflowers in the background and the sunflowers on the quilt or tablecloth in front of the women.  They focused a lot on the written bits of the collaged border and whether or not it was a blanket or part of a newspaper.  I was happy that they noticed the figure behind the women was Vincent Van Gogh, based on his looks and also their previous knowledge of his sunflower paintings.
  • VTS sessions always allow for the scaffolding strategies of Show and Tell and Give Time To Talk, as well as Use Visual Aids because students are studying a picture and thinking aloud about what their version of "what's going on" in that picture might be, therefore allowing for critical thinking.  As far as this image is concerned, the scaffolding technique Tap Into Prior Knowledge was definitely used, specifically when mentioning Rosa Parks and Vincent Van Gogh, two prominent figures from history they have previously learned about.  A strategy similar to Pre-Teaching Vocabulary is paraphrasing after each student comments about the piece.  This allows for students to hear a different, and often more complex, translation of the words they are using so that they can utilize new vocabulary in the future.
  • As mentioned before, I was surprised students didn't focus as much on WHO the African American women might be in the piece and instead were more focused on the way the quilt was being displayed.
  • And piggybacking on the above comment, I would like to VTS the image again with a similar class of students to see if they could come up with more historical narratives based on who the female figures might be.  I would also be interested in using this image when introducing a unit on quilts in art and the stories they tell that I created in my Curriculum in Art Education class.

1 comment:

  1. First, let me say that I love this class! They have become textbook VTSers in your hands! Your gesturing and paraphrasing are consistent and effective. You are connecting student responses and this modeling is causing students to do the same.

    It's fascinating how authentically many student answers recognized Ringgold's intent and methods and yet, they didn't put a damper on the discussion or limit creative interpretations. Your conditional paraphrasing allowed this to happen. Kudos!

    You commented about your students' reticence to delve into the actual identities of the African American women. One thing you might do if you use this in the future and the same issue arises is to ask, "What do you see that makes you think this could be Rosa Parks? And then, if the response is unclear or the student admits not knowing a lot about that historical figure, you could the ask, "Does anyone else have any ideas about how this might resemble Rosa Parks?" and "Where might go to find out more about that?" You might also invite the original respondent to do a little research and bring the info back to the group during the next class period. If this particular student is one that needed a little self-esteem or motivational boost, this could fill the bill.

    You connected VTS to scaffolding strategies very thoroughly which demonstrates your in depth understanding of the method and its processes.

    One thing you might focus on as you move forward is ensuring that you meet each comment with the same level of enthusiasm. You were clearly warm, enthusiastic, and encouraging in each responses to all students, but sometimes extra exuberance for an answer might give the impression to some students that their answer was a little more exciting to you than another's. In some classes, though probably not this one, it could lead to competition that could be conterproductive. Just a thought.

    Great job, Ashley! This was a wonderful selection and a very successful VTS discussion!!
    You're becoming masterful at this! Yeah!!

    ReplyDelete