Monday, May 6, 2013

Blog Topic #9: Teacher's Choice Proposal


The Sunflower Quilting Bee at Arles (1991) -Faith Ringgold
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_l267nyD5yI1qzy9rqo1_500.jpg

I chose this image by Faith Ringgold for my Teacher's Choice Proposal because my young, 4th grade students are very interested in images that are bright, colorful, and have a lot of potential for various narratives.  The figures are painted stylistically and the diversity of the way the females are painted will provide them with expressive content.  The image is accessible in more ways than one.  For instance, students will find it very interesting that an artist they recognize, Vincent van Gogh, makes a cameo in the middleground.  I also like the fact that it isn't a painting on canvas, that students will be able to make connections to the quilted border.

Blog Topic #8: VTS-to-Date

  • Student Engagement and Learning:
    • Students were as willing as ever to participate in the 3rd VTS discussion.  I don't think they approached the discussion differently than in previous VTS sessions.  Yes, they have gained experience using the strategy, but they have always been a very engaged group so I don't see that there have been major changes in the ways they have participated since the beginning of the semester.
    • Student responses aren't necessarily different, but I have tried to remind them before each session to make sure they only make one statement when their names are called.  I love how thorough they want to be with their observations, but that tends to lead to others not having a chance to speak, or the same observation being mentioned over and over.
    • I think at this point the quality of the discussions has remained very good.  My group has always been quite comfortable speaking their minds about the various works of art, and that hasn't changed.  This has been a rough time to introduce VTS to my class because of how much schedules have had to be rearranged due to snow days, lessons I needed to teach before the end of the year, programs at school, and other variables.  The class has done very well with the introduction to VTS, but I don't know how much growth I have seen.
    • Some of the observations students made during the 3rd VTS discussion were:
      • The child has been injured. She is sitting on an adults lap, her face looks sad, and there looks to be a scrape on her knee.
      • The child is sick. Her face looks pale, there is a pot of something next to the people that looks like medicine, and there is a cabinet above the two people that looks like a cabinet that holds medicine.
      • It looks like the people have been quarantined because of their sickness. They look pale like they are sick and the blinds are drawn on the window like they have been locked in.
      • It looks like the child is an orphan. The lady that is holding her looks like a nun and sometimes nuns run orphanages.
      • The person holding the child is a man. It looks like he is going bald.
      • The person holding the child is a woman, it looks like she is wearing jewelry.
      • The person is a man, it is not jewelry, it is buttons on his shirt, and he is wearing red pants, there is just a blue blanket over his pants that looks like a skirt.
      • It looks like the building is from the south, because in the south, the buildings are made of clay, and that’s what the wall of this room looks like it’s made of.
      • It looks like there has been a natural disaster that has wrecked their house. They are very sad looking, and there seems to be a lot of things out of place, especially by the bed or chair on the right.
    • Student interactions during this lesson were as good as ever, with the exception of getting a little off track because of the office calling my room and my principal needing to pull me aside to ask me a brief question.  One difference during this discussion was that there were actually some amicable disagreements made.  The students disagreed as to whether or not the adult subject was a man or a woman.  No one got their feelings hurt, and I do think this has been a positive gain made by my students.  I think they realize that VTS is a good way to practice voicing their different and unique opinions.
  • Reflective Practice:
    • Thus far, I have learned that VTS is a great way to get students involved in talking about artwork, and that it is an invaluable part of an art classroom starting at a young age.
    • I feel like I am able to use the questions and prescribed teacher behaviors comfortably during most sessions, but I do still tend to gloss over the second question unintentionally.
    • As mentioned above, the problems I am seeing are students giving multiple observations all at once, leading to me forgetting to ask the second question.  I have also had trouble with finding plenty of time to facilitate the discussions and get my class on schedule with the projects my other 4th grade classes are completing.  I'm hoping starting VTS in the fall and getting into a groove right off the bat will help that situation next year.
    • I have been pleasantly surprised by how well my class has adapted to the VTS process and am looking forward to introducing the process to more classes in the fall.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Viewing Assignment: "A Discussion of 5th Grade Students"

After watching the video "A Discussion of 5th Grade Students" my thoughts were that the teacher did a great job of paraphrasing his students comments.  At times the students pointed out several different details, and he managed to remember them all in sequence and demonstrated more than one way to explain their thoughts.  As we have learned, paraphrasing lets students hear useful vocabulary that they can use in the future.  I think one thing he was forgetting to do was acknowledge responses in a warm and supportive way.  I don't think he was hurtful in forgetting, or that it impacted the engagement particularly negatively, but in the future, he might get involvement from more shy students if he provides more encouraging acknowledgments after each comment.  The teacher seemed a bit nervous, like a lot of people tend to be when there are cameras or other observers (besides students) around, but I think with more practice using VTS, his discussions will continue to improve and be a great asset to his students.

Blog Topic #7: Common Core Survey

The beginning stages of using Common Core State Standards (CCSS) in the Fine Arts department at Liberty Public Schools began about a year ago.  I have had meetings within my school, as well as with my department to discuss the importance of the switch to these standards.  The focus thus far has been on the English Language Arts Standards, and I am currently reading a book called Pathways to the Common Core: Accelerating Achievement by Lucy Calkins, Mary Ehrenworth, and Christopher Lehman (2012), which focuses on literacy.  From my reading, I have learned certain important aspects about the ELA Standards, such as the CCSS aim to put every state on the same measuring stick (p. 12).  It's interesting to me that there have never been nation-wide assessments given consistently, and these standards focus on creating "higher levels of accountability for student achievement" (p. 12) and create a basis for credible judgments across the country.  The CCSS also strives to emphasize much higher-level comprehension skills than previous standards (p. 9), place equal weight on reading and writing, and emphasize reading complex texts (p. 10).  Even young children are now being asked to read increasingly complex texts, make inferences and analyze them in multiple ways, and write their assessments, so that they can understand the text more thoroughly than ever before.  The CCSS are creating a "spiral curriculum within which teachers across the K-12 spectrum share responsibility for students' progress" so that growth can occur in student learning from year to year.  In this way, the CCSS convey that intellectual growth occurs through time, across years, and across disciplines (p. 11).  Most important to me, I have learned that the CCSS support cross-curricular literacy teaching (p. 12).  It is my job to figure out ways to align learning in my classroom with skills assessed in the Common Core so that students can make cross-curricular connections.

I think the push toward CCSS is an important one for all educators because of the above goals.  It is so necessary to show students that there are multiple ways of learning the skills assessed in these standards, and VTS is a great way to implement said skills with my students.   As mentioned in the video from the Northwest Museum of Arts and Culture we watched in week 6, "when [students] summarize and talk about literacy, or when they observe experiments in Science, or when they're doing problem-solving in math, those same skills that they use during VTS apply to those content areas."  Using VTS along with the CCSS can also help create a classroom environment where, as Eisner (2002) discusses in this week's reading,
more importance is placed on exploration than on discovery, more value is assigned to surprise than to control, more attention is devoted to what is distinctive than to what is standard, more interest is related to what is metaphorical than to what is literal. It is an educational culture that has a greater focus on becoming than on being, places more value on the imaginative than on the factual, assigns greater priority to valuing than to measuring, and regards the quality of the journey as more educationally significant than the speed at which the destination is reached
References:

Calkins, L., Ehrenworth, M, & Lehman, C. (2012) Pathways to the Common Core: Accelerating  Achievement. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

Northwest Museum of Arts and Culture and Garfield Elementary
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lspi5W8F4ww

Eisner, E. (2002).  What can education learn from the arts about the practice of education?  Retrieved from http://www.infed.org/biblio/eisner_arts_and_the_practice_of_education.htm

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Blog Topic #6: Video 1--Lesson 2/Image 1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vIiTwJv71U

Fellow VTSers: above is the link to my first video...I apologize for the sound not syncing up correctly, I'm not sure what happened there.  It is public so everyone can view it.  Does anyone know how I can give each of you access to my channel if I make it private?

  • Assessing Student Engagement and Learning:
    • Most students were very willing to participate in this VTS discussion.  I think they were actually kind of excited they were being videotaped, even though I assured them they would not be visible on the recording.  I still have a few students who have yet to contribute to our VTS sessions, including "Drew".  We talked about some ways to get him more involved at our on-campus class last week, but if anyone has tips for getting other students in the class more interested in contributing, I'd appreciate your suggestions.
    • A few observations the students made about the artwork were:
      • Some buffalo might have stampeded into Indian ground, because of the buffalo running around and the teepees.
      • An animal skin was painted on.  Maybe they used it for a rug.
      • There are Native Americans in the middle of the picture.
      • A map has been drawn of where the Native Americans are going to go to make a trade with someone.
      • Indians are hunting buffalo because you can see the horses and you can see the people on the horses have drawn their crossbows.
      • A picture has been printed on buffalo hide of a war that has happened.
      • The picture is a map where the teepees stand for the Indian tribes and the buffalo are pictured where they've found buffalo.
      • There's a mouse shape and a bird shape and those are the two symbols for the Indian tribes, and the picture tells the tale of the history of the war between the tribes.
      • There are different types of Indians pictured so it is a war story about one tribe trying to take the territory of another tribe.
      • The picture tells the story of the Indians dancing so that they can summon the buffalo and feel where they move.
    • Based on watching the video, I think students did a good job of interpreting their observations because they each found different details in the piece and then came up with many different ideas about what was going on.  I think this occured because students feel comfortable discussing their ideas and like to express their opinions to their peers. 
    • There were constant interactions between students during this VTS discussion.  It impacted group meaning-making positively because they love to bounce ideas off each other and build off of ideas their peers have stated previously. 
    • The discussion concluded with me praising my student's observations and reminding them that we could continue to VTS the image because we can always find new things to talk about within the image.  Due to time constraints that day, I had to cut the discussion a bit short. 
    • I think students are feeling very comfortable with VTS and are eager to talk about what they think is going on in the artwork we are viewing.  They are learning to listen carefully to their peer's opinions and finding creative ways to discuss what they think the artwork is about.  They are also learning that discussing artwork can be a very positive experience and that it is fun to share their individual points of view.
    • I have observed students raising their hands over and over during the discussions as they hear what others have to say so they can add to their original thoughts.  Their behavior during our VTS lessons has been stellar so I know they must be enjoying the lessons thoroughly.
  •  Reflecting on Practice:
    • The VTS discussion felt natural, but I did feel a bit rushed because of the aforementioned time constraints of the day.  I learned from facilitating this lesson that I need to work on memorizing my prepared introduction better so that the beginning of the lesson goes more smoothly.
    • Watching the video made me realize that I kept forgetting to ask "What do you see that makes you say that?"  I guess because my students are typically very thorough in their explanations of what they think is going on, I gloss over the second part of the question.
    • I don't think there were any major surprises during this VTS lesson.  My students did a very good job staying focused and coming up with excellent observations.
  • Planning:
    • For the next VTS lesson, as I mentioned before, I want to work on my prepared introduction so that future students feel the same comfort level right off the bat that my current students feel for the process.  Second, I need to remember to ask the second question each time a student finishes his or her observation.  Last, I would like to make sure I get involvement from all of my students by the end of the year. 
    • To accomplish the above, I am going to write out my introduction and practice it with peers, or maybe students in other classes.  To remember the second question, I am going to make a poster for the back of my classroom with the questions listed so that I am reminded during each VTS lesson what I need to ask.  To ensure that I get all students involved, I will try pulling aside students that are hesitant about the process and ask them what would make them feel more comfortable during VTS and work on facilitating their needs.  If anyone else has suggestions, I'd love to hear them!

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Blog Topic #5: Portrait of Possibility

Getting my VTS class back on track has been a nightmare the last few weeks.  Snow days, end of quarter activities, and a district-wide Fine Arts week have completely rearranged my schedule, so I have only seen my VTS class once in their regular rotation.  I'm doing my best to go with the flow and get back on track!

For my portrait of possibility, I'm choosing the quirky, loveable, always well-meaning, but terribly anxious "Drew".  Drew's family moved to Liberty about two years ago, and the change was a difficult adjustment for him.  I'm not sure what prior experience Drew had in art, but he really struggled to find his niche in my classroom.  His parents and I emailed one another quite a bit during his first year at Liberty Oaks, trying to figure out how to make the best of his art experience.  I spent a lot of time focusing on him and talking him through assignments, trying to build his confidence.  His parents were wonderfully supportive.  They took him to several art museums and got him very interested in different types of artwork.   

He's doing much better now, as far as creating art goes, but I'm noticing a disconnect when we have our VTS sessions.  Drew is mildly autistic and suffers from dilapidating anxiety.  There are days when the poor guy comes to class crying because he couldn't sleep the night before, or he had a stressful morning.  His classmates are very supportive and I always make a point to check in with him when we're working on projects, but when we do our VTS discussions, I notice he is very unfocused and antsy.  Because my part of VTS is very scripted at this point, I'm not sure how to regain his attention appropriately, or get him interested in contributing to our conversation.  Drew is extremely intelligent and I know he could come up with some awesome discussion points if only I could figure out how to focus his attention on our lessons.  I think having a more active role in the VTS discussions could really help Drew's confidence in art and ease his feelings of anxiety about getting answers "right" or "wrong".