Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Read and React Week 2

I found myself on the fence about my agreement/disagreement with this week's readings.  There's a part of me that wholeheartedly agrees with the idea that traditional (old-fashioned???) methods should be taught so that those types of skills don't disappear.  Am I so traditional that I adhere to Keen's ideology that the Web 2.0 movement is one that worships the creative amateur?  Not necessarily.  My views were ingrained into me by my art professors in college, and my wonderful high school art teacher before that.  I can't help but feel like knowing these types of techniques built a solid foundation on which I can now more successfully add technological skills that are relevant for modern times, not set me apart as an "elite talent."

I did find myself agreeing with the excerpt from Daniel Tapscott's Grown Up Digital.  It gave me hope for newer methods of teaching and learning.  For the most part, I found myself agreeing with Tapscott's musings about the Net Generation.  He told personal stories often based on observing his own children's dealings with technological advances that seemed to somewhat surprise him and mystify him.  For instance, daughter Niki's internet life was considered by her to be a refuge from adults, allowing her to indulge in the Net Generation norms Tapscott describes: 1) freedom; 2) customization; 3) scrutiny; 4) integrity; 5) collaboration; 6) entertainment; 7) speed; and 8) innovation.  Using these norms, Net Geners transition into their twenties and the workforce with a sense that it's a period of "self-discovery and self-realization," as mentioned by Tapscott's son Alex.

But does all this self-involvement taint relationships with others?  Is friendship "slipping from our grasp?" as stated by Deresiewicz?  While Net Geners demand the above norms listed by Tapscott and the choices that come with them, they don't seem to be only looking out for "number 1."  "A record number of Net Geners...are volunteering for civic causes."  And the passage I found most uplifting in favor of this generation in Grown Up Digital was this: "the stereotype that this generation doesn't give a damn is not supported by the facts.  Net Geners care about integrity--being honest, considerate, transparent, and abiding by their commitments.  This is also a generation with profound tolerance."

In Wolf's selection, it was stated that "the immediacy and volume of information should not be confused with true knowledge."  I thought that quote went well with Tapscott's discussion of colleagues his age believing his April Fool's joke about Angelina Jolie joining him at work, without a lick of fact checking.  He then states that these same baby boomers tend to find the variety that comes with technological advances aimed at Net Geners to be burdensome, even when it could help them sift out the truth.

For Net Geners who need this multitude of choices, our current model of democracy wouldn't be sufficient to meet the needs of Net Geners: "four years of listening to politicians endlessly repeating the same speech?"  No thanks.  The products of this generation are also the "new scrutinizers...Given the large number of information sources on the Web, not to mention unreliable information, today's youth have the ability to distinguish between fact and fiction" -or- "trust but verify."  I identify with the last quote because of my gut reaction to always question if photographs have been photoshopped or if information has been embellished.  This discredits Wolf's assumption that technology drives us to believe whatever pops up the fastest.  Maybe it makes me and the Net Geners sound very cynical, but I think it stems from the old adage, "fool me once..."

More cynical even than any Net Gener could dream of being, is Bauerlein's opposite end of the spectrum look at Net Geners, The Dumbest Generation, which pans the generation Tapscott praises.  Just as "the old ones did when Elvis arrived," Bauerlein complains of a youth culture that eschews adult imparted knowledge for peer-to-peer relationships (through "digital tools") that extend "to every minute and every space of the day and night." He claims that the more the Net Geners attend to themselves, "the less they remember the past and envision the future."

Test scores or not, I think this overgeneralization of a an entire generation is false.  To say that everyone before now are so much more knowledgeable of historical or current events gives too much credit where it isn't due.  I personally know a lot of people my mother's age (and even folks as old as my grandparents) who would need a refresher on historical facts and especially on current foreign and domestic affairs to take the tests Bauerlein gathers his statistics from.  The information they could give you would probably be swayed heavily to one side or the other, depending on which political party their friends get their information from.  As Bauerlein later says, "think of how many things you must do in order NOT to know [basic facts]."  I think a lot of people, Net Geners and preceding generations included, go out of their way to bury their heads in the sand.

As mentioned above, this generation is often considered cynical as well as unmotivated but entitled.  As teachers, it's up to us to use technological advances to our advantage in order to find ways to motivate and help students find and create meaning for themselves.  And occasionally "unplug" in order to see beyond that technology (and not take things for granted), like Bartunde Thurston.

1 comment:

  1. Ashley this is a wonderful reflection. You did a fantastic job weaving all of these viewpoints into a succinct narrative. Though I think Bauerlein brings up some interesting points as far as discussion, in general I think his accusations fall into the "Back in my day" category. For some reason any time I read him I am reminded of Dana Carvey's grumpy old man sketch from SNL (check it out here: http://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/digital-shorts/video/weekend-update-segment-dana-carvey-as-grumpy-old-man/1358135/).

    I think that young teachers today are in a position of both power and insight. You have the memory of the "time before" and function well in the time "after" - what better position for you to weave the balance of digital and analog lives 21st century students need? :)

    ReplyDelete