Sunday, February 3, 2013

Blog Topic #2: Peer Practice

For my practice VTS lesson, I chose the Winslow Homer image, "Dad's Coming".  One of my favorite aspects of being an art teacher has always been having discussions about various works of art with my students.  Children are typically very vocal about their ideas on the meaning of artwork, but I found it somewhat difficult to have that same interaction with my peers.  They were subdued and seemingly intimidated at the beginning of the lesson by the idea their answers would be "wrong".  After much assurance that wasn't the case, they agreed to participate in my peer group.  They opened up and created various narratives for Homer's somber sea scene.  It was interesting to hear my peers begin to bounce ideas off of one another.  One even came up with a detailed description of events that unfolded before our small group's eyes.  "In the sky are dispersing clouds, as though there has just been a storm," he said. "A sailor must be missing at sea due to the storm and his wife and children are wondering if he's okay or if they will ever see him again."  The others began to take notice of other details around the figures, such as the sailboats in the distance that "might be out searching for the lost sailor" and the debris littering the beach that could be further proof of the storm that had recently occurred.

I think overall it was a good experience for my peers to discuss artwork in a way that they've never felt comfortable doing before.  The feedback I received was overall very positive, and most agreed that frequently asking "What else can you find?" pushed them to look closer at the painting and take in details they may have otherwise ignored.  For some, the probing made them feel like they were "missing something they should have noticed".  They did feel, however, that with more VTS practice, that somewhat negative feeling would subside.  They also agreed that the VTS method is something they can adapt for their own classrooms to facilitate a level of critical thinking important for student's cognitive development.

2 comments:

  1. Yeah!! I'm doing cartwheels over this blog post! Isn't it amazing how that sentiment that there is "a right answer" is so intimidating, even to adults??

    I loved that they began to construct narratives and "boot strap" on the ideas of others. I've read lots of blog posts from VTS I students who have used this image and your group is the first that saw the debris on the beach. This just proves that no two discussions of the same artwork are alike and how important peer groups are to visual comprehension.

    I also like that they understood the importance of Question 3; that it made them continually go back and notice more deeply.

    Yeah!! (Cartwheel again!) You must have nailed this inaugural VTS performance because your peers grew from fearful skeptics to engaged meaning-makers. LOVE it!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know I am behind on comments and you are probably well past this initial lesson but I wanted to share something that might help with the viewers who feel they are "missing something". I really worked on my neutral comment after every viewer. My word is "good". This might help your viewers to feel they gave a satisfying answer. ??? Just a thought. I find I now use this neutral comment even when students are sharing in class. I hope you are loving VTS with your students.

    ReplyDelete